- Joined
- May 31, 2016
- Messages
- 16,592
- Reaction score
- 28,827
This definitely annoying AF and shouldn't happen. The bottom is more of the issue though.I just went over @patfanken 's latest thread, which are his thoughts immediately after the game without the benefit of any film. The other posts are all over the place, from people questioning the intent or positivity of other posters, to talking about Bill, Brady, drafts, coaches, etc. Sure, there's a couple of tweets here and there from Lazar and others but there's mainly opinions based on "eye test" after watching the game on TV or stuff completely unrelated to the game itself.
You're last sentence is key though. For example the rewatch threads were ok, better than nothing I guess but 99% of the post were someone clipping a tweet with non original thought. It just became the Lazar thread.I'm not sure that's what @BaconGrundleCandy and @One-If-By-Sea were referring to when they spoke about Content based threads. I was under the impression they were talking about analyzing the game by breaking down plays and film. That is sorely lacking on this forum, unfortunately. I have real questions about why the secondary performed so poorly against a rookie QB playing only his 4th NFL game, besides the fact that JC had a baby last week. I looked at film breakdown for the Bucs game and their WRs were open all night. Something is going on with the secondary and I'm not sure what it is but it would be nice if we spent time looking at it, just so we have a better understanding.
It would be nice to see a thread dedicated to breaking down the plays and analyzing what we think is happening (not me, not qualified) instead of having to sift through dozens of meaningless posts (as it relates to the subject matter, they're perfectly fine as opinions). I'm not sure there are enough qualified posters to get this accomplished but anyway, it is what it is.
It would be great if a posters stepped up in that regard. Even have everyone take a different position group so it's not overwhelming. I'd gladly take on OL/DL/QB for example. We just need more posters and voices. You don't need to be Bill Walsh to participate and ask questions to get a discussion going.