If Brady comes back 100% from his injuries, then I'll agree with you. As it stands, however, Brees is 100%, and Brady, in the last three seasons, has suffered a torn acl, torn MCL, something messed up in his shoulder, a serious foot injury, an injury to a finger on his throwing hand, and apparently a few cracked ribs.
As a result, he hasn't played to the level that he's capable of since 2007. Do I think he'll get back there? There's a good chance, yeah. But in the mean time, Brees is already at a level that's very nearly as good as Brady's peak. So, if I were given the chance to pick between the two of them, I'd take Brees. Not a knock on Brady, who's my all-time favorite player (seriously, just look at my name). Generally, though, you take the guy who's healthy over the guy who isn't. It's the same exact reason, actually, why I'd take Johnson over Moss. I'd take 2007 Moss over Johnson, and 2007 Brady over Brees, but it's not 2007 anymore and both of these guys have had some injury issues since then.
