I think we are beating the dead horse, bud. Bill 100% was wrong. I think he thought that FM/JJ could handle this with his supervision. I don't think it was Bill's masterplan, it was his master screw up. I don't think in a million years he thought these guys would foul this thing up as bad as they did.
I'm part of the guys that used to sit at the Altar of Belichick, as you say. An aside: I seem to remember Parcells using that term: sit at the altar an learn. To your point, what he did in the past is not the point, it's what he is doing now. 100% deserves to be criticized.
Re: Bedard. I find him to be a little smug. Comes off as the smartest guy in the room on his podcast, but he's not nearly as smart as he thinks he is. I think he was 0-4 on Wildcard weekend picks. I was listening to it while plowing snow this week, and remember thinking that he was way wrong, and his podcast didn't age well. (i listened after the games) I don't know the exact record, but I do know I laughed at him while he spouted off how XYZ was going to happen.