PatsFans.com Menu
PatsFans.com - The Hub For New England Patriots Fans
PatsFans.com - The Hub For New England Patriots Fans

A Quarterback's Game

Status
Not open for further replies.

mgteich

PatsFans.com Veteran
PatsFans.com Supporter
Joined
Sep 13, 2004
Messages
43,430
Reaction score
21,618
All the remaining 8 teams contending for a Superbowl have a top 10 quarterback. Only Rodgers and Roeslisberger (of the top 10) are not still in the hunt.

No team has survived without a top quarterback.
 
Yup, its all about the quarterback, and the rest are supporting cast who can make you lose, but can't make you win.
 
I don't think Flacco is a top ten QB and they won with him last year. He got hot and played well enough to compliment a D that was hitting it's stride. You don't need a top 10 QB to win a Super Bowl, you just need a QB who is playing at a top 10 level for 3-4 games (which, granted, is more likely to happen with an actual top 10 QB).
 
I don't think Flacco is a top ten QB and they won with him last year. He got hot and played well enough to compliment a D that was hitting it's stride. You don't need a top 10 QB to win a Super Bowl, you just need a QB who is playing at a top 10 level for 3-4 games (which, granted, is more likely to happen with an actual top 10 QB).

OK, let's call it "good QB or hot QB." Regardless, I can't imagine anybody saying "defense wins championships" again under the current rules. The losing teams on wildcard weekend averaged 25 points.
 
ya'll shouldn't be surprised. it's the golden era of QB. we have more legit QBs than ever before in the history of NFL

old lions
brady
peyton
rodgers
brees

young lions
luck
cam
wilson
kaep
foles

past SB winners
big ben
Eli
flacco

2nd tier QBs
rivers
smith
romo
ryan
cutler
stafford



that's more than half the league.
 
OK, let's call it "good QB or hot QB." Regardless, I can't imagine anybody saying "defense wins championships" again under the current rules. The losing teams on wildcard weekend averaged 25 points.

A good way to say it. Sometimes I play a game of semantics that nobody wins.
 
I don't think Flacco is a top ten QB and they won with him last year. He got hot and played well enough to compliment a D that was hitting it's stride. You don't need a top 10 QB to win a Super Bowl, you just need a QB who is playing at a top 10 level for 3-4 games (which, granted, is more likely to happen with an actual top 10 QB).
I would argue that the guy who plays like a top 10 QB in big games is mopre of a top 10 QB than a guy who just has nice stats all year.
What would you rather have?
A guy who is average all season and plays lights out in the playoffs.
Or a guy who puts up good numbers all year then doesn't get it done in the playoffs?
 
All the remaining 8 teams contending for a Superbowl have a top 10 quarterback. Only Rodgers and Roeslisberger (of the top 10) are not still in the hunt.

No team has survived without a top quarterback.
That list is very debatable.
Matt Ryan and Joe Flacco were sinches on it a year ago and many on it now wouldn't have been.
Before yesterday Dalton was on most peoples top 10 based uponthis season.
 
Of course the list is debatable. That's why many of us are here, to debate such issues.

I personally believe that all the of the 10 (the 8 plus Roth and Romo) are better than Flacco or
Ryan.

That we can be discussing over 16 quarterbacks as being top quarterbacks simple underlines the fact that this is a quarterback's league.

That list is very debatable.
Matt Ryan and Joe Flacco were sinches on it a year ago and many on it now wouldn't have been.
Before yesterday Dalton was on most peoples top 10 based uponthis season.
 
The losing teams on wildcard weekend averaged 25 points.

Well, I don't think that's a good measure, KC scoring 44 impacts too much the average, as three of the four teams didn't reach those 25 points.
 
Well, I don't think that's a good measure, KC scoring 44 impacts too much the average, as three of the four teams didn't reach those 25 points.

Median was close to the mean in this case -- only ONE of the eight teams playing last weekend scored under 20. And looking at this week's games, I expect more of the same.
 
Without even having to think beyond the last game of the weekend, the 49ers do not have a top 10 quarterback.
 
While it's fair to say this is proverbially a quarterback's game, based on 3 out of the 4 wildcard games, it's also equally as fair to state that the importance of the running game (whether from the running backs or the quarterback) is just as paramount as the quarterback play as well.

Based on the games themselves, the winning teams' QB's didn't have much of any huge statistical impacts that many were expecting, especially in the case of upper-echelon QBs like Brees and Rivers.

Neither one of them had great games statistically by any stretch of the imagination (Brees was arguably bad), and yet their teams were able to come away victorious largely in part because of the play of their running games. The 49ers were really no different, but aided with big gains from their QB using his feet.

That's not to say that this isn't a QB's game as stated, but I think the playoffs are taking on a different animal altogether. Teams that are more than willing to go to the ground game even if their QB's numbers suffered because of it, even in defeat in the case of the Packers and Eagles, and have that balanced attack seemingly had greater levels of success than those that did not. Sans their injury situation, Kansas City not running the ball in the second half as much as they should have been was their downfall IMO

Ultimately, that is what it's all about in the playoffs in my opinion. Running the ball effectively and having your QB making timely throws when called upon and playing mistake free football. No game further exemplified that than the Chargers-Bengals one.

So, yeah, it's a quarterback's game, but the running game is just as important at this time of year too. Whether it stays that way remains to be seen going forward.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
MORSE: Patriots Mock Draft 6 – A Week Before the Draft
TRANSCRIPT: Eliot Wolf Pre-Draft Press Conference 4/13
Patriots News 04-12, What To Watch For In The NFL Draft
MORSE: Pre-Draft Patriots News and Notes
MORSE: Patriots Mock Draft 5
MORSE: Patriots Mock Draft 5
Mark Morse
1 week ago
Patriots Part Ways with Another Linebacker as Offseason Roster Shake-Up Continues
Patriots News 04-05, Mock Draft 2.0, Patriots Look For OL Depth
MORSE: 18 Game Schedule and Other Patriots Notes
TRANSCRIPT: Mike Vrabel Press Conference at the League Meetings 3/31
MORSE: Smokescreens and Misinformation Leading Up to Patriots Draft
Back
Top