2024 NFL Immediate Re-Drafts

[JerseyShore99]

Who would you have rather picked with NE's picks that they used?

I'll share my meaningless re-draft now

1.3) Joe Alt, OT, ND
2.37) A.D. Mitchell, WR, Texas
3.68) Roman Wilson, WR, UM
4.103) Theo Johnson, TE, PSU
4.110) Audric Estime, RB, ND
6.180) Joe Milton, QB, TENN
6.193) Will Reichard, K, Alabama
7.231) Michael Barrett, LB, Michigan

UDFAs:

• RB DJ Williams, Arizona
• WR Drake Stoops, Oklahoma
• WR Jalon Calhoun, Duke
• G Javion Cohen, Miami (FL)
• EDGE Braiden McGregor, Michigan
• CB Storm Duck, Louisville
• K Harrison Mevis, Missouri

Yay or nay? I'm a fan and like the actual haul NE got...Even though I don't LOVE Maye, I recognize his upside...Obviously my mock sets us up for another high pick that would be used on a more polished pocket passer

 

[captain stone]

There's already a thread, but... Maye, like Corky 3 years earlier, was a pick they Had to make, though I would've Loved Joe Alt here.

Agree with the Mitchell pick; if they wanted a WR instead of a LT at 37 then they should've picked him and waited for Polk at 68.

Substitute Jaylen Wright for Estime, and that 4th round would've been Sweet.

Reichard & Barrett, at those positions, would've been UDFAs to me.

 

[JerseyShore99]

Who would you have rather picked with NE's picks that they used?

I'll share my meaningless re-draft now

15) Mac Jones, QB, Alabama
38) Assante Samuel Jr., CB, FSU
96) Amon-ra St. Brown, WR, USC
120) Tyler Shelvin, DT, LSU
177) Shemar Jean-Charles, CB, App. State
188) Tarron Jackson, DE, CCU
197) Shi Smith, WR, SC
242) Marvin Wilson, DT, FSU

UDFAs: Deon Jackson, RB, Duke; Dylan Moses, LB, Alabama; Tamarrion Terry, WR, FSU; Mark Gilbert, CB, Duke; Tommy Kraemer, G, ND; Javian Hawkins, RB, L-Ville; Zack Von Rosenberg, P, LSU

Who would you have rather picked with NE's picks that they used?

I'll share my meaningless re-draft now

1.29) Lewis Cine, S, UGA
2.50) George Pickens, WR, UGA
3.85) Daniel Faalele, OT, Minnesota
4.121) Brandon Smith, LB, PSU
4.127) Hassan Haskins, RB, Michigan
4.137) Kyren Williams, RB, Notre Dame
6.183) Cade Mays, OG, Tennessee
6.200) Derion Kendrick, CB, UGA
6.210) Chase Lucas, CB, ASU
7.245) Isaih Pacheco, RB, RU

UDFAs: QB McKenzie Milton FSU, RB Maeteo Durant Duke, WR Justyn Ross Clemson, WR Ty Fryfogle, TE Braden Galloway Clemson, TE Cole Fotheringham Utah, OT Tyler Vrabel BC, LB James Skalski Clemson, LB Colin Schooler Texas Tech, CB Shaun Jolly App. State, FS Nolan Turner Clemson, FS Isaiah Pola-Mao USC, SS Smoke Monday Auburn

Yay or nay? I do believe this tops NE's haul

Who would you have rather picked with NE's picks that they used?

I'll share my meaningless re-draft now

1.17) Michael Mayer, TE, Notre Dame
2.46) Cam Smith, CB, SC
3.76) Blake Freeland, OT, BYU
4.107) Stetson Bennett, QB, UGA
4.112) KJ Henry, DE, Clemson
4.117) Noah Sewell, LB, Oregon
5.144) Henry To'o To'o, LB, Alabama
6.187) Kayshon Boutte, WR, LSU
6.192) Jarrett Patterson, C, ND
6.210) Deuce Vaughn, RB, KSU
6.214) Dee Winters, LB, TCU
7.245) Michael Turk, P, Oklahoma

UDFAs: QB Malik Cunningham Louisville, RB Mo Ibrahim Minnestota, WR Jake Bobo UCLA, WR Jadon Haselwood Arkansas, WR Gunner Romney BYU, WR Aron Cruikshank Rutgers, TE Noah Gindorff NDSU, LB Cam Jones Indiana, FS Brandon Joseph ND

Yay or nay? I'm indifferent on NE's 2023 class, especially after I hated the 2022 class which is seemingly solid

Who would you have rather picked with NE's picks that they used?

I'll share my meaningless re-draft now

1.3) Joe Alt, OT, ND
2.37) A.D. Mitchell, WR, Texas
3.68) Roman Wilson, WR, UM
4.103) Theo Johnson, TE, PSU
4.110) Audric Estime, RB, ND
6.180) Joe Milton, QB, TENN
6.193) Will Reichard, K, Alabama
7.231) Michael Barrett, LB, Michigan

UDFAs:

• RB DJ Williams, Arizona
• WR Drake Stoops, Oklahoma
• WR Jalon Calhoun, Duke
• G Javion Cohen, Miami (FL)
• EDGE Braiden McGregor, Michigan
• CB Storm Duck, Louisville
• K Harrison Mevis, Missouri

Yay or nay? I'm a fan and like the actual haul NE got...Even though I don't LOVE Maye, I recognize his upside...Obviously my mock sets us up for another high pick that would be used on a more polished pocket passer

One has to think Mac Jones would have found some more success with ARSB and Pickens at WR with Pacheco and Williams in the backfield

 

[JerseyShore99]

Who would you have rather picked with NE's picks that they used?

I'll share my meaningless re-draft now

1.3) Joe Alt, OT, ND
2.37) A.D. Mitchell, WR, Texas
3.68) Roman Wilson, WR, UM
4.103) Theo Johnson, TE, PSU
4.110) Audric Estime, RB, ND
6.180) Joe Milton, QB, TENN
6.193) Will Reichard, K, Alabama
7.231) Michael Barrett, LB, Michigan

UDFAs:

• RB DJ Williams, Arizona
• WR Drake Stoops, Oklahoma
• WR Jalon Calhoun, Duke
• G Javion Cohen, Miami (FL)
• EDGE Braiden McGregor, Michigan
• CB Storm Duck, Louisville
• K Harrison Mevis, Missouri

Yay or nay? I'm a fan and like the actual haul NE got...Even though I don't LOVE Maye, I recognize his upside...Obviously my mock sets us up for another high pick that would be used on a more polished pocket passer

Alt looks like a franchise OT, but obviously a franchise QB in Maye has more value and has proven to be the right decision (next year will be telling) and maybe there are some players that will be productive NFLers in my haul (Mitchell, Wilson, Johnson, Estime, Milton), but we could have/should have rolled Reichard

Good thing I wasn't picking for us (Although Wolf didn't do much better)