At some point the tape was stolen and sold to Josh Miller, who remained in posession of the tape until Martin Gramatica stole it from him on August 23, 2006 - the day that Gramatica was released and the kicking job was given to rookie kicker Stephen Gostowski. Shortly thereafter, Miller was reported to have injured his shoulder and the Patriots signed Danny Baugher as insurance.
On September 22nd, Gramatica signed with the Colts to back up Adam Vinatieri. Walter, a retired punter and longtime friend of Vinatieri, asked Adam to steal it back for him so that he could use it as leverage to resecure the Patriot's punting duties. Vinatieri was succesful in stealing the tape from Gramatica on October 3rd. Gramatica accused Adam of stealing the tape and he was released from the Colts the next day.
Todd Sauerbrun, who has had a long time feud with the Gramatica brothers, caught wind of the dispute and offered Vinatieri a large sum of money for the tape. Vinatieri, despite his friendship with Walter, opted for the money.
Walter continued to bluff that he had the tape and was signed out of retirement by the Patriots on November 22, 2006. Howerver, after Todd Sauerbrun contacted the Patriots in mid December, Walter was placed on IR on Dec 17th and Sauerbrun was signed 4 days later on Dec 22nd.
Sauerbrun, whose heart was always in Denver, managed to free himself of his NE contract on April 18th, 2007 thanks to winning a grievance filed by the NFL Players Association. Having gotten what he wanted, he mailed the tape to practice squad punter Danny Baugher.
Baugher looked to be the leading candidate for the Patriot's punting job for the 2008 season. However, Danny's father Erle found the tape. Erle, a chronic gambler, had ammassed considerable debt and was in trouble with several lone sharks. He sold the tape on August 28th to an NFL collector who subsequently contacted several punters to auction off the tape to the highest bidder.
Danny's distraught phone conversation with his dad later that day was overheard and the Patriots subsequently release him on the 29th. Later than night, in an angry drunken stuper, Danny punched his dad in the face and was charged with assault and battery.
Meanwhile, the NFL collector's auction was bid on by Tom Malone, Josh Miller, Chris Hanson, and several other no-talent punters. On August 30th, Chris Hanson won the auction and was signed by the Patriots the same day.
Based on recent transactions (or lack thereof), it appears that Chris Hanson is still in possession of the tape.
The organization knows as POOP lives on and the Patriot's punting is a constant reminder.