Yeah, this was devastating. Contrary to most people, this loss hurts me more than any aside from 2007, because after every loss in the playoffs with B&B, i was sure that we were going to be right back the next season. I have absolutely no optimism that this was the start of something, instead of a magical season with the worst possible outcome.
All these ''we're on the right track, it's only year two, etc..'' takes naively consider only an upward trajectory which is never the case in this league. 31 other teams are also striving to be better, and all have the same resources. There were so many things that went in our favor this year, from the schedule, the injury luck, key injuries to our opponents, to a good but not even close to an unbeatable Seattle team in the Super Bowl. The Cowboys won three titles in four years, and haven't been to the SB in 30 years. There's absolutely no guarantee we make it back in the next ten. This was the chance, and the entire offense couldn't have disappointed more. 0, ZERO, points through 3 quarters in a Super Bowl. I have no idea what contingency plans they had for the wide variety of issues that came up, but we saw no adjustments whatsoever. What Vrabel did was just as bad as Belichick benching Butler. It was obvious that Campbell is a game-losing liability, and he never considered replacing him, even for a drive, to see whether Lowe is less of it.
Most of the good will Maye gathered with his really, really good regular season, he threw out the window with this post season. The defense got his back for three straight games, we had two weeks of rest, great weather, all we needed was one good, regular season-like performance and he couldn't deliver. The more tape there was on him, the better the defenses adjusted, and the worse he re-adjusted to them. I was convinced that he will take this rare opportunity and produce a great performance despite his previous three games, but he just couldn't do it all playoffs long. He was timid, scared and indecisive in the first half, and yet he was somehow worse in the second. A fumble that cost the team 7, while down only 12, a terrible, terrible interception while also down only 12, and a complete inability to see the blitz on his right side that resulted in a pick six down 15. Every time the team had a chance to bring it back to a one possession game, he turned the ball over, with catastrophic mistakes.
He played like Goff did in 2018, always late with his reads, no confidence, turning the ball at the worst possible time and a sense of inevitability from the first drive to the last. Goff never came back to the big game, that was his shot against a beatable Pats team, and he blew it. While we're at that game, we had 3 points against the Rams through 3 quarters, looking clueless, so in the last two SB's with McDaniels as OC, we scored combined 3 points through six quarters of play. That says it all about McDaniels' game planning. As soon as the opponent does something out of the ordinary, like Seattle blitzing more than usual, McDaniels is like a deer in the headlights, like he never even considered this as a possibility. He prepared for the most likely strategy by the opposite defense and every deviation is a shocker.
I honesty envy the people who just brush off this loss, like we've lost a wild card game by getting there with a 9-8 record. I wish i was more optimistic, maybe i'll be in a few months, but right now, this looks like a squandered chance that doesn't come very often for a team that has very little elite talent, and almost none on Offense with the jury still out on Maye.