- Joined
- Jul 3, 2013
- Messages
- 43,453
- Reaction score
- 50,080
Correct. Bill’s coaching record without Brady is absolutely part of his story. It’s not THE story but it’s part of it for sure. Why wouldn’t it be?11 years removing a single variable is a valid discussion. We aren't discussing a season or two where you can say "oh well the roster was similarly bad". 11 years is a career worth of time to evaluate someone without a single player in multiple scenarios with multiple rosters. Especially when that variable left and won a SB and also 5 playoff wins in 3 seasons (and made the playoffs all 3 times).
Like this is kind of silly. There is a huge difference between Bill with Brady and without him and Brady has shown he is far more of a constant without Bill. 11 years is not some ridiculous sample size to evaluate. That's more than Bill Walsh's entire tenure in the league. That's the combined time Parcells was on the Giants and Jets.
It's a fair discussion on him. And I already did compare him on this board to other coaches without their top HOF QB.











