Once again, there doesn't seem to be much nuance here and a lot of revisionist history. Sure Mac had to go; he was awful as described the last two years. In my estimation, as an athlete he had lost all confidence and this was a major reason why he declined so terribly. I think it's unrealistic to think that he would have been able to recover if he had remained in New England. So good bye. Having said that, for all of us who watched him play as a rookie, he was outstanding and that is as undeniable as the fact that he was horrible by the end. Statistically, he had one of the ten best rookies seasons of all time. He clearly tailed off by the end of the year, but check out the offensive cast at the skill positions and the offensive line supporting him. I hear all this nonsense regarding Brady's mistakes (when he made them) that he had no protection or no one to throw to. Go back and review Mac's receiver corps when he was a rookie as well as his offensive line; they were awful (Jacobi Meyers the number one, along with Agholor and Jonnu Smith) and despite a mediocre O-line (Wynn and Ted Karris on the right side), he was, for a rookie, outstanding. The first six games of the year he was getting killed yet still delivered the ball all over the field. That's just a fact. He had no problem throwing to the second level to a range of receivers and did an excellent job of reading the D and delivering the ball. If he recovers his confidence he can certainly be an NFL quarterback given a rookie season that got him into a Pro Bowl (as an alternate). We'll see if it happens and I would wager it would take a couple years holding a clipboard at a minimum but once an athlete loses his/her confidence of course they are done and Mac did so to an extreme degree. Was the coaching staff culpable for this, at least in large part? You bet. I don't get exited by a preseason game, but he was good for more than just this one game. He showed a lot of promise and then, for whatever reason, fell apart.