I like the extensions and all...but at some point how much money should we be re-investing into a four win team?
I dealt with the #9 Defense in another post. Our talent on Defense is one of a playoff team not a 4-win team. so, we shoul continue to spend money to retain the players who make us a top Defense and continue to draft an acquire players.
=========
OFFENSE
Do we have 4-win talent at RB, TE? at IOL? Of course not.
And we did what was needed to keep out top players and add a couple of backups. We re-signed or extended: Onwenu, Andrews and Stevenson. We added Gibson and Hooper. We should be adding another RB.
LET US FOCUS
We had FOUR major weaknesses: QB, coaching, OT and WR. We were the worst in the NFL at these positions, especially after losing Bourne to injury.
I think that we have done very, very well in addressing these needs.
QUARTERBCK AND COACHING
Maye, Brissett and a new coaching staff addresses to weaknesses. Are they playoff caliber? Certainly, not yet. But they are better than last year. Consider, that las year's coaching staff was coaching Jones and Zappe. They will continue to improve each year, as long as Maye is even an adequate starter.
WIDE RECEIVER
I truly feel sorry for those who think Wolf hasn't done enough at addressing the QB position. We lack a #1 QB. When we trade for one or sign one, this unit is as good as many playoff teams.
Is this enough to improve from last year's Parker, an injured Schuster, Douglas, Reagor, Thornton and an injured Bourne? Just adding a healthy Bourne and Osborne would have been a major improvement.
Osborn, Bourne, Douglas, a healthy Schuster, Thornton/Reagor/Boutte would be a major improvement, waiting for the #1 to be drafted or signed. We also drafted Polk and Baker. Even if the rookies are not at all ready, we will have a much better than 4-10 passing game.
BOTTOM LINE
If we had two average NFL tackles and even adequate QB play (read Brissett), we would sign a WR and be ready for the 2025 playoff hunt. It would be 2024, but it will take at least half a year for the Offense to learn and do well at executing a new scheme.
THE ELEPHANT IN THE ROOM
So, here we are, the ONLY unfinished business other than signing a top WR.
Perhaps Wolf could have done better, perhaps not. Our starting point is Love-Onwenu-McDermott. We may NOT have better overall talent at OT. After all, Onwenu will/should be moving to RG.
My hope is that we have enough to protect Maye. we need the new coaching staff to mold the players that we have into an OL scheme that is able to protect Maye and produce in the passing game and running game.
THAT IS THE 2024 CHALLENGE
Okorafor at LT and Wallace as starters is one answer (with Anderson as the swing and perhaps Love as the #4). If these four aren't enough, then we will need to trade or sign a vet to solidify the position for a year.
But there is no reason to expect failure at the challenge of having below average tackles, our only major weakness on the team.
YES, WE WILL BE LOOKING FOR A TACKLE IN 2025. Perhaps, we will sign or draft or LT starter and draft or sign the best LT backup we can find to be our swing (perhaps it will Okorafor).
Personally, I think that Wallace is an excellent prospect to be a 5-year starter. That's a HUGE, HUGE success. If so, if Maye is OK, we are two players away from a playoff competitive team: a #1 WR an starting LT.