Rodgers is such an enigma to me... Superb talent, but seems to shrink on most big stages. Always seems to get the most out of his receivers, but never gets his running game going. Appears to be overrated based on arm talent, but somehow won a Super Bowl with Mike McCarthy as his head coach, so he must be doing something right.
Too many question marks for me. Age, motivation, clutch ability, all at a cost that hamstring's your cap. That said, he instantly makes this team a playoff team, though I'm guessing he's not putting up with Meyers as his #1 for long, so we'd need to invest heavily there too. Plus with his age we'd need a 1st or 2nd round QB to start developing (which we probably do anyway).