Antonio Brown

[Todd Bradley]

I'm not getting worked up at all. But it is possible that the complaint underplayed her relationship with Brown while still having other evidence that we aren't privy to yet. I'm not saying that it exists. I'm only saying it's likely she is filing a lawsuit with more than she letting out in the complaint. That's what discovery is for. I'm a lawyer and just being realistic about the situation.

So...she lied in her official court filing about her relationship with AB, with video proof out that
s already against her, but the jury is still supposed to believe her civil suit for rape?

If that's the leg she's standing on, the judge will soon be throwing this out.

 

[karguy85]

They can do that but telling someone? Anyone can make that up you know. She already lied once. Her credibility is shot already. Defense lawyers would say well she lied about the relationship she had with brown.

Whether or not a defense lawyer would argue that the witness is lying does not negate the fact that circumstantial evidence is still evidence. Obviously it is better if it can be corroborated with phone/email/texts messages. I am just pointing out that there might be more there that Taylor's lawyers are not letting out yet so not as to embarrass Brown further so he might come to the table and settle before it gets out. There is a strategic reason, especially if the goal is to settle, to not show the public all your evidence.

 

[sambam94]

She claimed she had a strictly professional relationship with AB in her court filings and there's video all over the internet of them cuddling in bed and having fun, not to mention today's news and the fact that a civil lawsuit screams money grab to everyone with a brain.

Pretty safe bet, but hey if you want to get worked up about, by all means.

she stated brother-sister type relationship...not sure where strictly professional is coming from.

 

[PatsFan2]

Which will soon fall wayside just like the other nonsense this accuser with no credibility is claiming.

I told them 400 pages back that AB will be exonerated and no one believes me.

 

[NYCPATS4LIFE]

So...she lied in her official court filing about her relationship with AB, with video proof out that
s already against her, but the jury is still supposed to believe her civil suit for rape?

If that's the leg she's standing on, the judge will soon be throwing this out.

If the videos are dated and happen after her alleged rape she’s cooked. Brown’s reps say they where recent. Brown is probably holding on to them.

 

[karguy85]

So...she lied in her official court filing about her relationship with AB, with video proof out that
s already against her, but the jury is still supposed to believe her civil suit for rape?

If that's the leg she's standing on, the judge will soon be throwing this out.

It really depends how strong the other evidence is. Something like that will allow a judge/jury to make an inference to their reliability. It won't necessarily prove/disprove the case.

 

[NYCPATS4LIFE]

she stated brother-sister type relationship...not sure where strictly professional is coming from.

In her lawsuit it states that.

 

[Todd Bradley]

she stated brother-sister type relationship...not sure where strictly professional is coming from.

Oh yeah, brothers and sisters always lay in bed together half-naked......

 

[sambam94]

In her lawsuit it states that.

pretty sure the complaint states brother-sister, could be wrong though

 

[sambam94]

Oh yeah, brothers and sisters always lay in bed together half-naked......

just pointing out your mistake...and don't think she was half naked or lying down in bed

 

[Todd Bradley]

just pointing out your mistake...and don't think she was half naked or lying down in bed

She can say what she wants, but the proof says I didn’t make a mistake though.

 

[karguy85]

just pointing out your mistake...

And it's an important distinction. If that was what she said (I didn't read the whole filing) than you can make a good faith argument they had a close, familial relationship and those videos were taken within those parameters.

Of course, Brown's attorneys can make the argument that those videos show more than a familial relationship and, depending on when they were taken, are not how someone that was sexually assaulted/raped would act.

I find it unlikely that those videos would lead to dismissal of the case on a motion to dismiss or motion for summary judgment because they do not go directly to the allegations.

 

[NYCPATS4LIFE]

And it's an important distinction. If that was what she said (I didn't read the whole filing) than you can make a good faith argument they had a close, familial relationship and those videos were taken within those parameters.

Of course, Brown's attorneys can make the argument that those videos show more than a familial relationship and, depending on when they were taken, are not how someone that was sexually assaulted/raped would act.

I find it unlikely that those videos would lead to dismissal of the case on a motion to dismiss or motion for summary judgment because they do not go directly to the allegations.

They would if it was after her alleged rape. Who smiles and takes selfies with their rapist? We shall see what happens but something tells me she has nothing. Just going with my gut feeling.

 

[SBLIII]

Doubt it but we shall see. It’s all noise. Bring some facts. So now we can say all this stuff happened with no proof. Players are gonna have to protect themselves in the next cba from this clown commissioner.

I'm just saying if Goodell thinks he might be guilty he is going on the exempt and gone for the season.

with that being said it could open up a huge loophole

 

[sambam94]

She can say what she wants, but the proof says I didn’t make a mistake though.

ok....you didn't say they had a "strictly professional relationship". Must be an imposter

 

[rads2005]

I can’t believe there’s an article in the media about a doctor that claims “AB farted in my face repeatedly....and he owes me $11k”

That’s not even newsworthy in my opinion

The video is on TMZ. That particular aspect of the SI story is incredibly stupid. Doctor’s face isn’t near his butt and AB apologizes and says maybe he should leave.

 

[venecol]

Are you kidding me? Really? He’s gonna declare his innocence. This woman has to prove she was raped forcibly and she has already lied about the nature of their relationship. He has always stated it was consensual.

Aren't all rapes by their nature violent and forceful? Seems like a redundant adverb yet I've seen it used over and over. English is not my 1st language, so I'm not sure.

 

[Dingleberry]

Oh yeah, brothers and sisters always lay in bed together half-naked......

Haven't been to Seabrook, NH, I am guessing.

Family trees resemble telephone poles in that town.

But your point stands. Her story stinks.

 

[BadMoFo]

 

[BUSTAMOVE]

Oh yeah, brothers and sisters always lay in bed together half-naked......

They do in Oklahoma