Eavesdropping is not public.
When you are who they are saying it to the weekly shopper is ultimately the same level of public as holding a press conference. Just lol that you capitalize it and think it is more meaningful.
That's all you need to say.
You choose to believe a direct statement but create a fantasy world out of extenuating items.
You agree you know nothing about him and then go in to say why he would publicly lie (many times by the way) and personally think something else.
Of course you do or you wouldn't argue every little point.
I never said you were batshit crazy.
Then why are you wasting all this time predicting his demise?
What action? Keeping him as a backup says he likes him as a backup.
The gap from Brady to any other active QB is greater than the gap from that guy to "whoever".
That's the point. You can have the greatest of hope for garoppolo but it is TOM BRADY you are comparing him to. The GOAT. THE GOAT who is also currently the best player in the NFL. Who just CARRIED this team to 2 rings in the last 3 years.
One of hundreds of failures is worth their weight in gold?
I am an @ss for disagreeing with you?
You do realize that you just "called me out" for my opinion right?
Does that mean you are an @ss?
I am on a cell phone at work with crap internet and customers that keep interrupting me so perhaps I am not always as articulate as I would like to be. I have been a long time lurker here, as in I remember NEM's craziness and vendetta against the various OC's we have had through out the years. As such you aren't on my ignore list, one because talking about issues should never get to that point, and two because I have read you for years and know you as one of the quality insightful posters on this board. I am not calling out you or your opinion I am trying to get you to see how frustrating it is that you present your opinions as facts and the way you currently argue/debate this topic makes you look like an ass.
I am going to make this my last post of the subject so feel free to have the last word. I don't know what is going to happen with Brady and Grop going forward. What I wanted to happen didn't and as such I have had to readjust my expectations and I don't think that is an unreasonable position to take. I find Bill not trading Grop for the at least #12 pick that was offered to be a monster statement of what he thinks he has in Grop. A real franchise QB that can compete for a championship and with luck win one or two. Is he going to be Brady? Hell no, I doubt we see another Brady in the next 50 years. That said I feel 10 years of very good to great QB play is more important then one year of GOAT play. I watch football to be entertained and 10 years of entertainment is a long time. Having to root for a Brown's caliber franchise where just getting to the playoffs is a major accomplishment must suck. That's the sort of franchise you become without a legit starter at QB.
You talk about the gap at QB like Brady is a 100/100 and nobody else is even a 80. Maybe I am misreading and thats not how you mean it, but its how it sounds to me. I do think Brady is a 100 but Rodgers, Brees, Pay me a ton, choose your flavor are not that huge of a gap behind. Say they are a 95, what's that one extra play a game? Sure this game comes down to inches and a single play can make or break a victory but you take Brady out of that equation and a 95 is plenty good enough to win a Superbowl. Is Grop a 95? I would guess more like a 90 but he could be. That still isn't the 60-70 most of the QB's in the league are and most likely the sort of guy the patriots would end up drafting. How much do you give up to keep that guy?
That is the action I was talking about from Bill. He kept Grop over reported multiple high picks. Besides those actions what else do we know about him and what Bill thinks of him? When I am explaining my position I make sure to clarify that I am no high level insider, I am not Brady's best friend or confidant I am just another jamoke like all of you who reads everything Patriot I can get my hands on. I recognize that my opinion doesn't mean a damn thing and all I get is the tip of the iceburg when it comes to the real story. Expressing my opinion as a poorly informed opinion not fact.
I agree with you Andy that right now Brady is the best player in the NFL and is likely to still be that this year with a high probability of it being true next year. I agree he is owed the highest level of respect and admiration it is possible to give an athlete because he has gone so far and beyond anything we could have ever expected. I agree your source is the best possible one, the man himself saying repeatedly that he wants to play for another 5 years. I will even say you could be right and he will continue to be that player for the next 5 years and bring home another championship or two. If anyone can its Tom F'in Brady the man Hollywood couldn't make a movie about because it would be too unrealistic.
What I can't do is make sense of the different stories we are getting. Scheffter has a highly placed source in management that feeds him info. My bet is Jonathon Kraft but it could be Stacy James, Patricia, or Ernie Adams. He has been right more often then not. He was adamant that Grop would not be traded for any price. He has reported with equal assurance that Grop is in their long term plans. How can that be if Bill only values him as a back up? How does all of that add up when Brady is going to be playing for another 5 years? My answer is to go look at the one piece of information I have that doesn't fit the rest of the puzzle. Brady's comments. Why would he lie? You can call it making things up, living in a fantasy world or whatever you want but I can see Brady doing it to shut the media up about his retirement. Am I right? Again I am not Brady's best friend so I have no idea but I have listened to every interview and press conference so it could be. We will know in a couple years.
My absolute ideal world is for Brady to play for the pats the next two years, retire with a threepeat and seven rings. Grop then takes over in 2019 and the pats remain year in and year out contenders maybe winning another ring or two when everything goes their way. Probably not going to happen but a man can dream