Thats not the way the NFL generally works. The player has to guard against injury. Your plan suggests he just doesn't feel like playing sometimes so you will incent him to do so.
Not really. Its a recognition of a historical fact. Talib has missed at LEAST 20% of his games (not including the playoffs) in EVERY season he's played. Do you really want to guarantee a fully years salary to an employee who is only going to be there 80% of the time....at best?
No team is going to pay Talib what someone of his talent would get if he didn't come with such a consistent injury risk UNLESS the team gets some kind of protection. So in the end what's the big deal if instead of having a contract that pays him as a top 5 CB, but instead of the usual 50% guarantee, it only guarantees 33%. Forget about the other issues of being a corrupted protein shake away from a year's suspension, and other "character issues".
Maybe there WAS a time where all these things wouldn't matter, but not these days. Teams are much more intelligent about spending big money these days
The contract he has may be better than the one you can sign him for.
You get a straight salary deal, that is essentially a series of one year deals.
Good point, but a new deal might allow more flexibility to back load the contract if the cap is an issue the next 2 years
Cant endorse that last part.
Well in truth neither can I . But every April, as the draft gets closer, I get very jealous of those teams who actually have a chance to pick some of the players everyone is talking about.
Shut down corners make the defense special. Those moves just hope to incrementally improve somewhat.
That's why I would sign both Browner and Cook. Browner has been a successful press cover corner who would excel against some of the bigger receivers we face each week. Cook is a big corner, who has all the measurables to be that kind of CB, but hasn't. He's young enough that's there's still a chance he could be. Also both might be decent SS candidates, and situational coverages.
"Football is a numbers game". That was the advice a mentor of mine told me when I got my first HS HC'ing job. It was one of the best pieces of advice I ever had. Its true on the HS level and its true in the NFL. Its folly to put all your eggs in 2 baskets (as you suggest.) I'd rather hedge my bets and use the cap room from one of your CB's and improve the DL and LB areas, as well as taking a couple of low cost DB risks to get a similar result.