Okay, going to have my very first pop at this and see how I get on. Two disclaimers though (don't want to be held to these next April
)
1. Being based in the UK, I don't get to watch college football and I don't have the knowledge to effectively scout these players even if I did. What I do is research - seeing what is said about the prospects in various places, learning from previous drafts and developing ideas based upon that. How successful that approach is will be seen (although in last years prediction contest I did jointly win, predicting Solder and Vereen - probably a fluke).
This probably best represents my understanding of the draft.
2. I've only just started the research process and haven't looked at nearly enough prospects so this mini-mock will be a very early and incomplete guesstimate.
But here goes:
Trade Brian Hoyer for mid 2nd rounder
1. Trade 1A and 3 to move up ahead of the NY Jets
1A - Courtney Upshaw DE/OLB
Not sure BB will trade up for someone who doesn't fit the measurables for the position, nevermind drafting him in the first round, but I really like what I've read and seen of Upshaw. Screams "Patriot" to me and looks to be an immediate defensive upgrade. Wouldn't trade up too high for him but he's a good option for the Jets so moving up 3 or 4 places to jump ahead of them would probably be worthwhile.
1B Trade 1B for 2012 2nd and 2012 3rd (If Devon Still was available here, I'd take him rather than trade down but I don't think he will be).
2A - Dont'a Hightower ILB
The Patriots need to seriously upgrade their defense and as I see it only Wilfork, Mayo and probably McCourty should be seen as locks for next year. Hightower not only provides excellent cover but should compete with, and possibly beat out Spikes for the second ILB spot. He also has the added benefit of possibly being able to play as an OLB.
2B - Markelle Martin FS
At the moment it's him or TJ McDonald - I can't really decide. Would also be tempted by Sanu or the Baylor WR Kendall Wright if they were available. Still Safety is a position of need and with two linebackers already selected, there's no need for the DE/OLB conversion projects that seem to be rated in this spot and no 3-4 DE's that appeal.
2C - Ben Jones C
Not enthused by this but there's not a lot available in this range. Trade into 2013 perhaps?
2D Trade 2D for 2012 3rd and 4th
3A Marvin McNutt - WR
We see it so often. Sir Tom Brady (I'm British so I've adopted and knighted him) needs to feel comfortable with a wide receiver if he's going to feature in the receiving game. McNutt works in a pro offense, knows his routes and is a former QB and intelligent. If anyone is going to make Brady feel comfortable it's him right? And just to make you salivate - It's 3rd and goal, Brady has dropped back, Welker is in the flat and Gronkowski and the 6'4" McNutt are loitering with intent at the back of the endzone towering over 5'10" and 6' DB's. Who can say "TD" the quickest?
3B - Kheeston Randle DE/DT
Might not offer a pass rush from the 3-4 DE position, but is a 6-5, 305 pounder who plays low and eats up double teams. Can't ask for more in the bottom of the third round.
4 - DaJohn Harris DT/DE
Could probably be had later but I'm done working on trades as I haven't fully researched this end of the draft yet. Is a 6-4 310lb DT from USC and could be an interesting development option as a 3-4 DE.
Not a bad draft. Would love to have included Still, Sanu or Kendall Wright but didn't see the opportunity and I'm not overly keen on the likes of Worthy, Crick or Winn for the DE positions. On the other hand, I really like Upshaw and Hightower at this moment in proceedings and see them as upgrades for this defense. Glad to address the safety spot but would have liked to include a CB like Minnifield or Gilmore. Randle and Harris are development 3-4 DE's who might just make a spot their own.
On the offensive side, I'm not convinced an OK Centre is a desperate need but didn't see much else at that slot worth picking but McNutt may be my early binky and adds a TD threat to an already potent offense.
More work needed yet I fear.