upstater1
PatsFans.com Retired Jersey Club
- Joined
- Nov 29, 2005
- Messages
- 30,484
- Reaction score
- 22,841
You are overrating Butler. He is starting, but he isn't great. He has 18 tackles, 4 pass defenses, 0 INTs.
Besides, who cares what Butler is doing elsewhere? Just because his career has rebounded in Carolina, it doesn't change the fact he struggled in the Pats' defense. Some players just fit into one system over another.
So you think the Pats should have kept him so he could get smoked on the Pats defense just because he doesn't get smoked in a different system that obviously fits his skills more? Butler had three years here. He just wasn't a good fit here. What ever he does for the rest of his career doesn't change that fact.
The Jets cut Woodhead because he couldn't get on the field with him. The Dolphins let Welker go because he just didn't perform in their system. Some players excel in some systems and not others.
I haven't watched Butler. Only followed what Panthers fans have said about him, and they say he's playing really well.
By the way, he had 2 seasons in New England, not 3.
You're saying we're not allowed to question Belichick on D-backfield choices? Excuse me, but I saw with my own two eyes live how horrendously bad Barret and Brown were. I have huge doubts about Molden and Adams, given the incredible weakness at DB of the teams that cut them.
Are you asking me right now if I'd prefer Butler over Molden and Sanders over Barrett? Yes.











