This is a valid statement, but I think there are some factors that should be considered. Youth and depth are not a concern at halfback like it is at other positons, namely inside linebacker. I feel that by trading down with a team set on McFadden is a far more prudent decision. Top five pick money is a lot of money, especially to a halfback, and especially when you already have three highly capable halfbacks on the roster. By making this move, money is saved, the team remains in position to take a high-level prospect at ILB, and potentially add a future high level strong safety.
In my opinion, Maroney is a very good halfback. His skills are very complimentary to Sammy Morris. I philosophically disagree with a 25-30 carry a game back, so I feel that Maroney is ideal for a situational back system. It's very rare to find a back who can handle the responsibilites of being an every down guy. I mean, do you really want your 230 pound hammer running wheel routes on third down? Do you want your 185 pounder with joystick agility hammering the ball? Backs have different skill sets and should be utilized accordingly. The three back system enables the backs to remain fresh and combine to wear a defense down over time.
