Who is better Vrabel or Reid?

[Steve102]

Charlie Sheen level of winning going on here, we may be closing in on a head shaving followed by an assault on a keyboard with an umbrella

 

[Pape]

 

[Guts]

They're the 10th seed in the AFC.

They'll be in the mix of things after they kill the Cowgirls

 

[Dec54]

I thought this meaningless Troll had left. He is taking the piss of this forum

 

[imahobgoblin]

Did the asylum open and let all the fruits out today so they could make stupid post of the year candidates?

 

[Nikolai]

 

[DoubleDeluxe]

They'll be in the mix of things after they kill the Cowgirls

I am a firm believer KC is never out of it, until they are mathematically out of it.....
But Dallas can score in bunches and defensively they've been better.
I picked them this week, may pick them Thursday too.
That is far from a slam dunk for KC.

 

[TheRainMaker]

I thought you were leaving the board?

 

[Guts]

I am a firm believer KC is never out of it, until they are mathematically out of it.....
But Dallas can score in bunches and defensively they've been better.
I picked them this week, may pick them Thursday too.
That is far from a slam dunk for KC.

Queefs are against the wall and their this generation dynasty no way they lose

 

[DoubleDeluxe]

Queefs are against the wall and their this generation dynasty no way they lose

Normally I would agree.
I picked them this week against Indy without giving it a seconds pause.
Dallas is different tho, that offense can score and KC has been pretty inconsistent.
Indy can score too, but if you limit Taylor they rely on Jones. He's been ok this year, but he's not near as good of a QB as Dak is when he's hot.
I'm not set on my pick yet, but I wouldn't be surprised with a Dallas win.

 

[signbabybrady]

I'm not sure how anyone can say it's not Reid. He runs the offense, groomed the best QB in the league, and has multiple rings.

I'm not even sure Vrabel is even in charge of the D. You'd think with Williams out he'd step in but its clearly been Kuhr. And McDaniels runs his offense and has been grooming Maye. What is it Vrabel even does?

 

[ahmed]

Are we talking about Andy Reid? What kind of dumb question is this?

 

[maust]

Are we talking about Andy Reid? What kind of dumb question is this?

The not really a question kind of dumb question

 

[DoubleDeluxe]

Are we talking about Andy Reid? What kind of dumb question is this?

It may be a dumb question, but a coach is only as good as his QB usually.
Look at BB's record without Brady.
Reid went to the SB with McNabb who was a 6 time pro bowler in his career, and Patrick.
Does Reid make it to a championship game without those 2?
If Vrabel coached Mahomes when KC was at their best does he make the SB?
Maybe not such a dumb questions after all.

 

[NFL Mystique]

It may be a dumb question, but a coach is only as good as his QB usually.
Look at BB's record without Brady.
Reid went to the SB with McNabb who was a 6 time pro bowler in his career, and Patrick.
Does Reid make it to a championship game without those 2?
If Vrabel coached Mahomes when KC was at their best does he make the SB?
Maybe not such a dumb questions after all.

Reid made the postseason four times with Alex Smith. He won a postseason game with washed up Jeff Garcia and rejuvenated Vick's career.

Who is the OC if Vrabel is Mahomes HC?

 

[DoubleDeluxe]

Reid made the postseason four times with Alex Smith. He won a postseason game with washed up Jeff Garcia and rejuvenated Vick's career.

Who is the OC if Vrabel is Mahomes HC?

That’s a valid question.
He would need a good OC no doubt.
Good coaches are smart enough to surround themselves with good OCs, like Reid had done with Spags.
Reid obv has the edge on Vrabs.
Just pointing out that every “great” coach becomes great when they have a great QB.
Vrabs went to the AFCC with Tannehill. That’s no small feat.

 

[Kdo5]

If you choose Belichick as one of the GOATs due to winning championships you have to choose Reid over Vrabel.

 

[A Defiant Goose]

If you choose Belichick as one of the GOATs due to winning championships you have to choose Reid over Vrabel.

Not necessarily. BB has a couple of staple wins that you could largely attribute to his defense (2001, 2018). I'm not sure you could say the same about the Chiefs

 

[Patriot Missile]

Some sarcasm meters are broken here. He’s just making fun of some of the posts over the years by certain BB haters that would randomly make posts like these. All he is doing is inserting Vrabel in Belichicks name. The posters know he has directed these to them.

 

[Ian]

Locking this thread. Way too early to make this comparison.