When does TB come out of the game? [mergedx2]

[JDP111]

Cassell and Guttierez Should share QB duty in the 4th...

Let's get #12 outta there and see the kids sling it around!!

 

[He Ban Me]

Re: When does TB come out of the game?

He Ban Me, when Peyton was tearing it up in '04, what were you thinking about the whole situation? Did you really care if he seemed like he was "padding" stats or did you just want to see him and he Colts win and destroy every record they could?

Well, the longer ago it was, the harder it is to remember. Sure, I wanted him to do it, but 49 was so many that I don't think it was spoke of this early. I don't think he ever threw 5 in the first half anyway. AND, I don't think he ever threw a TD pass up by 28. I don't begrudge a NE fan for wanting him to stay in and throw more, it's a ton of entertainment. AND, that was my question, I think it is almost a slap in the face to take him out at the half. So, I think if Manning were ahead 42-7, midway through the third, I'd bench him.

 

[upstater1]

Re: When does TB come out of the game?

Seriously? There were several talking heads, players and coaches that basically called the Patriots classless in several ways throughout the entire camera-gate incident.

I don't speak for them. I still think he should have come out early.

 

[fair catch fryar]

Re: When does TB come out of the game?

I don't speak for them. I still think he should have come out early.

Fair enough. Years from now, I just want to be able to look back on this season, shake my head, and grin when people begin to debate the greatest QB's of all time.