The scoring algorithm for this game is wicked frustrating. It just doesn't like certain players. Try taking Joel Bitonio before the 4th and you get a B to B+
I have no clue how people are getting over 6000pts. After a week and about 100 playthroughs, here's the best scores it's gave me:
Your score is: 5992 (GRADE: A)
Your Picks:
Round 2 Pick 30: Marcus Martin, C, Southern California (A)
Round 3 Pick 7 (CLE): Austin Seferian-Jenkins, TE, Washington (A)
Round 3 Pick 25 (S.D.): Demarcus Lawrence, DE, Boise State (A)
Round 3 Pick 28 (CAR): Kelcy Quarles, DT, South Carolina (A)
Round 4 Pick 15 (NYJ): Bruce Ellington, WR, South Carolina (A)
Round 4 Pick 30: Charles Sims, RB, West Virginia (A)
Round 4 Pick 40 (COMP): Ahmad Dixon, SS, Baylor (A)
Your Future Picks:
2015 Round 1 Pick
2016 Round 1 Pick
Your score is: 5649 (GRADE: A)
Your Picks:
Round 1 Pick 29: Timmy Jernigan, DT, Florida State (A)
Round 2 Pick 30: Jace Amaro, TE, Texas Tech (A)
Round 3 Pick 29: Weston Richburg, C, Colorado State (A)
Round 4 Pick 30: Charles Sims, RB, West Virginia (A)
Round 4 Pick 40 (COMP): Trai Turner, OG, LSU (B+)
Round 6 Pick 22: Kevin Norwood, WR, Alabama (A)
Round 6 Pick 30: Taylor Hart, DE, Oregon (B-)
Round 7 Pick 29: Andre Hal, CB, Vanderbilt (A)
Your Future Picks:
2015 Round 1 Pick
2016 Round 1 Pick
Your score is: 5634 (GRADE: A)
Your Picks:
Round 2 Pick 17 (NYJ): Dee Ford, DE, Auburn (A)
Round 2 Pick 30: Marcus Martin, C, Southern California (A)
Round 3 Pick 16 (NYJ): Kelcy Quarles, DT, South Carolina (A)
Round 3 Pick 29: Telvin Smith, OLB, Florida State (A)
Round 4 Pick 30: Arthur Lynch, TE, Georgia (A)
Round 4 Pick 40 (COMP): Phillip Gaines, CB, Rice (A-)
Round 6 Pick 22: Dri Archer, WR, Kent State (A)
Round 6 Pick 30: Vinnie Sunseri, SS, Alabama (A)
Round 7 Pick 29: Rajion Neal, RB, Tennessee (A)
Your Future Picks:
2015 Round 1 Pick
2016 Round 1 Pick
Your score is: 5625 (GRADE: A)
Your Picks:
Round 2 Pick 31 (DEN): Austin Seferian-Jenkins, TE, Washington (A)
Round 3 Pick 12 (DET): Weston Richburg, C, Colorado State (A)
Round 3 Pick 29: Bruce Ellington, WR, South Carolina (B+)
Round 3 Pick 31 (DEN): Demarcus Lawrence, DE, Boise State (A)
Round 4 Pick 10 (STL): Joel Bitonio, OT, Nevada (A)
Round 4 Pick 11 (DET): Yawin Smallwood, ILB, Connecticut (A)
Round 4 Pick 30: George Uko, DT, Southern California (A)
Round 4 Pick 31 (DEN): Trai Turner, OG, LSU (B)
Round 4 Pick 40 (COMP): Phillip Gaines, CB, Rice (A-)
Round 6 Pick 22: Jonathan Newsome, OLB, Ball State (C+)
Round 6 Pick 30: Vinnie Sunseri, SS, Alabama (A)
Round 7 Pick 14 (DAL): Rajion Neal, RB, Tennessee (A)
Round 7 Pick 16 (DAL): Kevin Norwood, WR, Alabama (A)
Round 7 Pick 23 (DAL): James Wilder Jr., RB, Florida State (A)
Your Future Picks:
2015 Round 1 Pick
2016 Round 1 Pick