Shocking move: Peyton traded for Brady!

[pats1973]

That being said, how many of you would take this trade?
Brady for Manning + 2 first round picks.

I personally would rather keep Brady than get 2 first round picks and Mr. 0.500, but I'm still curious to see what you guys think.

I think you're insane.

OP, great thread title!

 

[TheGodInAGreyHoodie]

That being said, how many of you would take this trade?
Brady for Manning + 2 first round picks.

I personally would rather keep Brady than get 2 first round picks and Mr. 0.500, but I'm still curious to see what you guys think.

The trade would never happen. Brady is too valuable to the Patriots and Manning to the Colts.

BB would not even begin to consider it for anything less than Manning + 1st round pick for Brady. And BP would not even begin to consider it for anything less than Brady + 1st round pick for Manning.

As for Manning + 2 - 1st. In a NY second. While Brady is the better QB, Manning is a franchise, HOF QB as well. What ever drop off in passing between the two QBs would be more than made up in the improvement of other aspects of the game by two first round players.