pdangle
Rotational Player and Threatening Starter's Job
- Joined
- Dec 6, 2008
- Messages
- 1,074
- Reaction score
- 613
Registered Members experience this forum ad and noise-free.
CLICK HERE to Register for a free account and login for a smoother ad-free experience. It's easy, and only takes a few moments.How can Vollmer be rated anything less than A+ ?
That rating system is absurd and totally nonsensical. Cunningham a D?
Whatever you're smoking, may I have some?
Does Cunningham make a difference in our D? He's made that one nice play pressuring Manning but what has he done? TBC and Ninkovich are our starters or play the most snaps and it's not like those guys are top OLBs. If Cunningham were to get hurt and not play anymore, would that make a difference? I say no. How can you then give him higher than a D?
Cunningham played 12 more snaps than Ninkovich last game and it was only recently that TBC saw appreciable time.
I'm absolutely flabbergasted that you apparently believe, with a straight face, what you wrote. I'll just leave it at that.
Tyrone McKenzie is on Tampa's Practice Squad. That is hardly washed out of the league..
Ohrnberger is currently on the Pats roster. Again, hardly washed out of the league.
I broke it down by looking at how our team would get affected if these guys got hurt.
A's: Our team would suffer significantly if these guys got hurt.
B's: Not as huge an impact as the guys I gave an A to, but still significant.
C's: Our depth would get hurt, but the level of performance from whoever replaced them I feel would be the same.
D's: If these guys get hurt, what's the difference? I guess you could lump them with the guys I gave C's to.
Brace starts in the base 3-4. Not sure what else you want.Brace C - Rookie season was a wash and has been in the rotation at times during this season. But for a 2nd rounder, I expected him to be vying for a starting position every game (like Chung/Vollmber)
What your doing is not a draft analysis but a team analysis. You can't ignore draft position in a draft analysis without getting ridiculous results (see previous posts).