OT: Worst "Peyton is better than Brady" argument ever

[Joey007]

First mistake reading YouTube comments...

I second this. They almost make Jets fans look smart, and I think we all know that's saying alot.

 

[Efstratios]

I second this. They almost make Jets fans look smart, and I think we all know that's saying alot.

I think I read a YouTube comment onetime that accused TB of being a selfish prima donna who throws his teammates under the bus whenever the Pats lose, and that he should be more of a leader like Eli. At that point I realized that there was far too much stupidity on YouTube, and that for the sake of my sanity, I should stop reading the comments on there.

 

[Disco Volante]

I personally think the "Patriots went 11-5 after Brady went down and the Colts were the worst team in the league!" is one of the worst ones.

Also, Peyton Manning has had a top 10 defense five times...

#1 (2007)
#2 (2005)
#7 (2002)
#8 (2009)
#10 (2008)

...and was eliminated in their first playoff game 4/5 of those years, with a combined 0 rings in all 5 chances.

 

[PatsWSB47]

I second this. They almost make Jets fans look smart, and I think we all know that's saying alot.

let's not go to extremes

 

[lurker1965]

Are you voting for Bush or Kerry?

I'd reply, but I can't top that and would not want to even try.

Good one - my hat's off to you, sir.

 

[TheBeers]

The funny thing is that there is a 100% chance the NFL pregame newly expanded 8 man idiot talking head panel featuring guest LaDainian Tomlinson drum up this comparison and arguments for Peyton before our week 5 game against the Broncos.