Delicate Genius
Generally aware
2020 Weekly Picks Winner
2024 Weekly Picks Winner
2025 Weekly Picks Winner
- Joined
- Mar 22, 2006
- Messages
- 8,157
- Reaction score
- 12,700
Texans (1), Broncos (2), Chargers (5), and Seahawks (6)
1 (SEA), 2 (HOU), 3 (DEN), and 9 (LAC) if you go by points against in the regular season.
For comparison, below is every Super Bowl-winning QB since 2000 and the total defense rankings of their playoff opponents that year. Mahomes in 2023 is the only one who played a top-10 defense every round, and even then, all four were outside the top-5.
'00 Dilfer: 24-1-17-5
'01 Brady: 18-1-3
'02 Johnson: 14-4-11
'03 Brady: 12-11-8
'04 Brady: 29-1-10
'05 Roethlisberger: 28-11-15-17
'06 P. Manning: 16-1-6-5
'07 E. Manning: 2-9-11-4
'08 Roethlisberger: 25-2-19
'09 Brees: 20-6-18
'10 Rodgers: 12-16-9-2
'11 E. Manning: 12-32-4-31
'12 Flacco: 26-2-25-3
'13 Wilson: 4-5-19
'14 Brady: 8-11-1
'15 P. Manning: 21-9-6
'16 Brady: 1-12-25
'17 Foles: 9-1-29
'18 Brady: 9-31-19
'19 Mahomes: 28-21-2
'20 Brady: 2-4-9-16
'21 Stafford: 11-13-3-18
'22 Mahomes: 24-7-3
'23 Mahomes: 10-9-6-8
'24 Hurts: 5-26-13-9
1 (SEA), 2 (HOU), 3 (DEN), and 9 (LAC) if you go by points against in the regular season.
For comparison, below is every Super Bowl-winning QB since 2000 and the total defense rankings of their playoff opponents that year. Mahomes in 2023 is the only one who played a top-10 defense every round, and even then, all four were outside the top-5.
'00 Dilfer: 24-1-17-5
'01 Brady: 18-1-3
'02 Johnson: 14-4-11
'03 Brady: 12-11-8
'04 Brady: 29-1-10
'05 Roethlisberger: 28-11-15-17
'06 P. Manning: 16-1-6-5
'07 E. Manning: 2-9-11-4
'08 Roethlisberger: 25-2-19
'09 Brees: 20-6-18
'10 Rodgers: 12-16-9-2
'11 E. Manning: 12-32-4-31
'12 Flacco: 26-2-25-3
'13 Wilson: 4-5-19
'14 Brady: 8-11-1
'15 P. Manning: 21-9-6
'16 Brady: 1-12-25
'17 Foles: 9-1-29
'18 Brady: 9-31-19
'19 Mahomes: 28-21-2
'20 Brady: 2-4-9-16
'21 Stafford: 11-13-3-18
'22 Mahomes: 24-7-3
'23 Mahomes: 10-9-6-8
'24 Hurts: 5-26-13-9
Last edited:












