Hate the player or hate the laundry?

[JGaffney]

It's a pure hypothetical - the Colts aren't going to let the Forehead go to another team. But suppose they did? I couldn't figure out for myself - would I hate Peyton's new team more or less than the Colts?

So: Suppose Sayton Manning went to a new, neutral team - i.e. not a currently commonly hated (Jets, Browns, Fins) nor liked (KC) team, and one similarly in the AFC but not our division.

Assuming one is a rational human being who already hates both Peyton and the Colts with the fires of a thousand burning suns (albiet with a grudging respect), who do you root against more, his new team or the Colts?

 

[CheeseMonkeys]

The Colts because they have been a longtime rival of NE.

 

[IcyPatriot]

I don't hate Manning and i do enjoy watching him play.

I don't hate the colts either and I do enjoy watching Wayne & Collie at work.

Now let's move on to Bill Polian ... that's where my dislike comes to the surface.

 

[pwes]

The colts. I'm not a fan of the entire establishment from the owner down to the fans.

 

[patchick]

I...don't really hate Manning at all.

:scared:

 

[Uncle Rico]

I'd probably mind him less if he played in Seattle.

 

[sbpatfan]

I don't like Manning because he plays for a rival team and is good. I hate people like Ben Rapistberger.

 

[blackglass3]

As long as Bill Polian is in Indy, they get my hate. Over the rivalry, I have really come to respect Manning. He's one of the best, and we are lucky to get to watch him and Brady duel at least once a year.

 

[420jim]

Its the laundry. I only hate the Browns for 1 reason.