Good trade or Bad Trade?

[VJCPatriot]

I've been offered Jamal Lewis RB (Browns) and Deion Branch WR (Seahawks) for Joey Galloway WR (Bucs) and Carnell Williams RB (Bucs).
So is this is a good deal for me? Vote now!

 

[frankiesfly]

i think it's a good trade. Branch should be more productive than Galloway. Even though I think Both RB's are going to be up and down all year, I would rather have Lewis. I don't like Williams at all.

 

[BAM!]

I kinda agree with Frankie, I think Carnell Williams is soft and won't hold up the entire year. I think Jamal will hold up but he is playing on the Browns and I think that last game against Cinci is an anomoly and not the norm. He will have to face the Steelers and Ravens D twice this year.

I think Branch is better than Galloway however, I think Galloway will have a couple of huge games wheras Branch is going to be more of a consistent WR.

I can't answer the poll because this is (in my mind) a pretty fair trade. Remember, Branch never had a 1,000 yard season with Brady throwing to him and the Seahawks have Shaun Alexander.

BTW, if the Bucs have a bad offensive day (which is highly possible), then both Galloway and Williams will suffer. So in that respect I would say go for the trade. It's just Lewis is going to going up against some much stingier D's, like the Pats.