What Butler allegedly did (we still don’t have a definitive answer) still doesn’t warrant punishing the rest of the team taking a veteran player out of the biggest game of the year.
Chandler Jones ends up at the police station the night before the 2015 AFCCG shirtless and high (who played), but Butler gets benched in the Super Bowl for not being “locked in” or something?
Aside from that, I hope he apologized for his atrocious game plan to the defense getting embarrassed and looking unprepared for the RPO.
Eric Rowe, Jordan Richards and Johnson Bademosi are asking you to hold their beers.
What Butler did was let his contract status effect his level of play, he was their worst starting player all season. From game one when he wouldn't communicate with Gilmore which forced them to bench Stephon.
The Eagles WR's were all 6'1" and bigger, the Pats played their best corners. And frankly the Eagles WR's did next to nothing in the 2nd half after they put Gilmore on Alshon Jeffrey. The only receiver that did any damage in the second half was Zach Ertz and it wasn't because Malcolm Butler was missing, it was because (a strong safety, not a corner) Chung got hurt and they had to replace him with Jordan Richards who got abused.
Butler sucked all year, he got embarrassed by Jay Cutler and 5'6" WR Jakeem Grant then blamed it on the coaches afterwards.
"Worst victim of a trampoline jump: Diminutive Dolphins wide receiver Jakeem Grant leapt up and snatched a 25-yard touchdown in the third quarter over Patriots cornerback Malcolm Butler."
"Best dropped dagger: Grant beat Malcolm Butler badly on a go route in the fourth quarter that would have been, could have been a game-clinching touchdown, but the ball slipped through the receiver's hands."
www.bostonherald.com/sports/patriots/the_blitz/2017/12/best_and_worst_of_patriots_loss_to_dolphins
www.weei.com/blogs/ryan-hannable/malcolm-butler-calls-his-pro-football-focus-retweet-after-mondays-game-big
The Patriots lost that Super Bowl because Alan Branch, Jonathan Jones, Donta Hightower then Patrick Chung were hurt for the Super Bowl.
Butler is and always has been overrated. He got exposed as a Titan and lost his job to Adoree Jackson last season before getting hurt, he's on the short list of vets to be cut by Tennessee this season. He peaked in 2016, he was a lesser talent who looked good on a great defense here and because he had a similarly sized Darrelle Revis to emulate.
He wasn't the reason they lost, he likely would have made it worse and he wasn't the reason the Eagles rushed for 164 yards in the Super Bowl... that was due to the 350 pound hole missing in the dead center of their defensive line and Hightower to boot.
The Eagles were simply the better team due to injuries on the Patriot's defense.