- Joined
- Feb 4, 2018
- Messages
- 22,185
- Reaction score
- 29,189
Honestly feel Hightower was a better player....
I started watching in the 90's when Parcells was around so here's my MLB rankings:It's not just a feeling on your part. Hightower was a better player! So was Bruschi, Ted Johnson, Andre Tippett, Mike Vrable, and Rob Ninkovich. And except for Hightower, the other guys weren't even 1st Round Draft Picks (and Hightower wasn't in the Top 10).
1. Ted Johnson. The league had so many elite MLB’s it was almost impossible for him to crack the Pro Bowl or All Pro. I've been watching old games and announcers were saying he was their best defensive player. Was an absolute violent hitter. My favorite Pats LB.
2. Teddy Bruschi. Sat behind Ted Johnson for good reason, but was a spark of energy for the 3rd down defense. He finally got his chance to start in 1999 when Todd Collins departed and Ted Johnson was injured. 2001 is when Bruschi started the transition to becoming the player we knew him to be, but 2003 is when he broke out.
3. Donta Hightower. I thought his transition to MLB was weird, but he pulled it off. He was an underrated outside rusher and I wish Bill would've used him like a Chris Slade. I'm guessing this couldn't be done since they were pretty weak at MLB. Had two game changing plays that helped his team win the Super Bowl.
4. Jerod Mayo. I've already had my rant in a previous post.
5. Andy Katezmoyer. This guy would be ranked higher had he not sustained a career ending neck injury. He was looking legit in his first season as a pro. He was initially drafted to take Todd Collins spot at OLB, but Ted Johnson's injury forced him to play inside. He finished his first season with 79 total tackles, 1 INT which he took to the house with ease, 15 tackles for loss and 3.5 sacks. He was going to be a star.
6. Brandon Spikes. I loved Spikes at Florida and thought he'd been perfect as a MLB with the early 2000's Pats when they switched to a 3-4. However, he was over drafted in the 2nd round. While he was limited athletically, he made up for it being known as a guy who could knock you out. More plays from Spikes stand out more than Mayo.
7. Ja'Whaun Bentley. Like Mayo, he's a stat collector with not much impact. He doesn't have any plays that make you go "wow" and stand out. He's extremely limited in space and gets exposed on crossers and competent players.
8. Elandon Roberts. Everyone's favorite whipping boy back in the day. Known best for picking the wrong gap. He was a gambler and when he guessed right, he was like a missile being fired. He's had a decent career finding starter jobs since leaving the Pats.
9. Gary Guyton. Hyped up for his speed, but he certainly didn't show it much.
10. Monty Biesel. Just checking to see if you're still reading. Best known for getting run over by a QB.












