IllegalContact
PatsFans.com Retired Jersey Club
- Joined
- Jun 5, 2010
- Messages
- 31,809
- Reaction score
- 16,273
He sucked, anyone who knows football knows that. I stake my reputation on it.
good for you
Registered Members experience this forum ad and noise-free.
CLICK HERE to Register for a free account and login for a smoother ad-free experience. It's easy, and only takes a few moments.He sucked, anyone who knows football knows that. I stake my reputation on it.
************, anyone who would bring up Terry ****ing Glen in this conversation!.No. His career regular season stats, whether over time or at their height, compare unfavorably to guys like Terry Glenn, Joey Galloway, Stevie Johnson, and Keenan McCardell. Guys who have no shot of ever getting in. Welker is a longshot and he was a better player.
Think about all the receivers he'll be competing against who will be up after he retires: Torry Holt, Hines Ward, Reggie Wayne, Steve Smith, Larry Fitzgerald, Andre Johnson, Brandon Marshall, AJ Green, Wes Welker, Antonio Brown, Emmanuel Sanders, Jordy Nelson, Demaryius Thomas, eventually Julio Jones and TY Hilton. Not all of those guys will get in, and - homer goggles off - is there any of those you wouldn't have traded for Edelman straight up at their height?
Edelman's been a tremendous player and truly clutch in the playoffs but playoff stats simply mean little to voters except for quarterbacks. And Edelman also doesn't belong in the Hall of Fame. He's not an all-time great. He's never been among the 5 best WRs in the league. He's not Randy Moss, he's not Jerry Rice, he's not even near Cris Carter or Andre Reed. Cliff Branch has far better regular season stats, All Pros, three rings, comparable playoff stats, and was only a semifinalist twice and has no chance of ever getting in. Edelman has no chance.
But he is an all-time great Patriot. He'll get that red jacket and deserve every thread in it. We'll never forget him.
Only Hall of Famers from this era of the Patriots are Brady, Belichick, Gronk, and (insofar as he counts) Revis. Slater will be a semifinalist or whatever as they nod to special teams mattering but never sniff a finalist bid, just like Tasker. It's a while out but White could sniff it too. Lots of truly memorable players for all of us though. But let's be honest, the lack of the Hall of Fame or even All Pro caliber players beyond the QB and coach hint at just how great Brady and Belichick have been.
************, anyone who would bring up Terry ****ing Glen in this conversation!.
Before last night I was firmly in the "no" camp.
His post season performances (which is why you play the game) are making me rethink my position.
Actually, championships more so. If you ever get to Canton, check out the busts and the descriptions, there are a great deal of multiple champions. for every Marino and Kelly ( no rings) there are guys like Swann and Stallworth whose post season heroics got them in.. Not saying Edelman can get in but 3 rings bolsters his cause...Probowls are as important as the stats to HOF voters. Edelman has none so no shot.
I don't think he makes it : which makes me wonder "why even have a HoF" ? You play to win the game... not the September 24th game. THE game.
I agree with you : he won't make it.Because it is a team game and the HoF acknowledges the best of the best individuals. While the postseason adds hype in the end those are just another set of football games and don't erase what you have done over the length of the previous 16-18 weeks.
Look I get that Edelman is a clutch player but he has not yet met the threshold to be considered a historic player. Add in a big season, a pro bowl ticket and another SB MVP and maybe he can be talked about from the angle of how "you can't tell the story of the NFL without mentioning him".
Yea, see....I think he already has.I don't think much changed in his case to be honest.
He put himself into a position now to get that ProBowl ticket next year with that added exposure of a SB MVP title if he has another big season. If he can add another huge postseason with a second SB MVP on top of that he might be able to overcome the lack of regular season accolades.
But honestly his biggest problem will just be the logjam at WR. Unless the HoF changes the way it does things I just don't think the numbers will ever work out in his favor.
What is the diffence between he and Swann ? Both VG regular season players with amazing SB wins.
And Edelman has the second most catches and yards in postseason history and a SB MVP.His regular season statistics are comparable to Edelman's. He had several seasons over 1000 yards and 5+ TDs. Edelman has one.