I agree that Wrong Borges is part of the reason that the Patriots have been snubbed when it comes to HOF induction, at least in comparison to the support for induction for players from teams that have won considerably less than the Pats. I don’t think it’s because he himself opposes the induction of guys like Harrison or Stanley Morgan, but rather that he sucks at playing the political game that is so obviously needed in that realm. Probably his ****ty personality and history as a plaigerer hurts the cause.
The Van Natta article demonstrates how deep the rot is in the election process. Kraft’s candidacy hasn’t even gotten past the committee level. Although the committee process is shrouded in mystery I have no basis for blaming Borges for the Kraft issue. It is news to me that the committee goes to lengths to hide things, but that’s entirely in line with the impression I have that the process is corrupt. I have no doubt that this is about people selling their votes and screwing candidates based on personal grievances; why else would they want anonymity.
Additionally the election process is inevitably driven by statistics, and that is to the disadvantage of guys from the Pats who played crucial roles in the first dynasty periods such as Bruschi, Brown, McGinest, etc. whose individual stats compare unfavorably to guys at the same positions who played for lesser teams. It’s the downside of playing in the BB system that succeeded through team excellence as opposed to individual excellence (I’m not in the “it was all Brady” camp, obviously his extraordinary performance was the most critical element, but still for me their unprecedented success was more about their excellence as a team). Nobody in their right mind would put Devin Hester on their football team over Troy Brown unless they only cared about kick and punt returns and nothing else, but Hester’s unique numbers are undeniable and in my view worthy of his election.
One final point I found notable here from the Van Natta article. For some time I’ve been quite skeptical about what BSPN has published from Van Natta and Seth Wickersham. They have on multiple occasions IMHO published things that nobody else covering the team regularly either also published or verified. I tend not to believe things written by someone parachuting in like that over what the local guys write or otherwise report. This piece about Kraft gives me pause, it sure feels like to me that he’s carrying water for the Krafts which to me implies more of a connection between them than I was previously inclined to believe existed. It does, however, align perfectly with my feeling that getting Bob to the HOF before he croaks is a higher priority to “certain people in the organization” than I would like (feel free to give me another dislike on this
@archstanton543 since you hate to see people imply such things about your beloved Nebbish).