BradysBunch12
On the Game Day Roster
- Joined
- Sep 17, 2009
- Messages
- 373
- Reaction score
- 0
Registered Members experience this forum ad and noise-free.
CLICK HERE to Register for a free account and login for a smoother ad-free experience. It's easy, and only takes a few moments.He was at 85.7 and now at a much more respectable 89.1 and ahead of Peyton. 36 TDs in 20 career postseason games and a TD in 18 consecutive postseason games. Not too shabby.
More importantly, 15-5 in the postseason.
Can you make a full comparison with Peyton's?
Brady: 15-5
Peyton Manning: 9-10
Montana's post-season QB rating is 95.6.
Bradshaw's is 83.0
Wins and losses is more important.
Montana's post-season QB rating is 95.6.
Bradshaw's is 83.0
Wins and losses is more important.
Interestingly, when you do look at the QB ratings, you find that Montana was more of a high/low guy than Brady. Montana had 2 games with a QB rating in the 30s and one of 42.0. Brady's lowest ever was the 49.1 he had against the Ravens. On the other hand, Montana had 12 games with a rating over 100 (High of 147.6), while Brady's only had 7 (High of 141.4). Montana's also had 5 games with a rating over 120 compared to 3 by Brady.
it hasn't been that Montana's been decidedly better. It's been that Montana has been more uneven, but has put up more excellent and lousy games, while Brady's had more games with a QB rating in the 70's (5-1), and both have 5 games in the 80-100 range.
Obviously, given their respective records, both ways have worked.
So....
100+
Montana 12
Brady 7
80-100
Montana 5
Brady 5
70's
Montana 1
Brady 5
50-70
Montana 2
Brady 2
Under 50
Montana 3
Brady 1
Montana played 3 more games than Brady has to this point, as well, so the Patriots making the Super Bowl this season would make them just about even in games played (Montana will have played one more at that point).
Montana's post-season QB rating is 95.6.
Bradshaw's is 83.0
Even including Brady's epic performance last night, his playoff QB rating went from 85 to 89, trailing Montanta's 95.6 which is even more remarkable for Montana in the pre-Flag Football era.
Also, including last night's epic 6TD performance, Brady is at 36TD/17int in 20 playoff games, while Montana still has the better playoff ratio at 45 TD/21int in 23 playoff games.
Brady has the better record, has been more consistent, and has played with a lesser supporting cast.
| 21 | 4K |
| 13 | 894 |
| 10 | 616 |
| 14 | 965 |
| 17 | 788 |
From our archive - this week all-time:
April 5 - April 20 (Through 26yrs)











