"Matty Heisman" shouldn't even be int he running, and I'm a BC student (abroad for the year). I was at the Wake Forest game, in which he looked okay at best, and the Army game, in which everyone praised him for looking amazing but he actually was awful. Sure, running up garbage TDs on Army is all well and good, but he was throwing some terrible passes and got picked off a couple times, including once inside his own 5 for a pick six. Everyone who was at the game couldn't believe when he was announced as the player of the game.
Of course, it doesn't help that BC has some absolutely horrendous WRs. Tom Waddle is the last respectable BC receiver I can remember.
EDIT: Guess I should insult him more, eh?