Experienced Starter w/First Big Contract
These aren't my evaluations of the players straight up, but rather my evaluations of how they've justified the new contracts:
Underpaid: Judon, Karras
Seems about right: Bourne, Mills, Van Noy
Minor overpay: Henry, Godchaux, Anderson
Comical overpay: Agholor, Smith
This isn't to say even Agholor or Smith are lost causes. In camp, reports were that Agholor looked like our best WR at times, and I certainly liked what I saw from Smith over Henry before the real games were played (after which my opinion turned around completely).
I think some people will take offense that I placed Henry in one of the "overpaid" tiers. I just don't think 600 yards and 10 TD (roughly his full season projection), without elite blocking ability, is worth $12.5M/year.
I think Van Noy is overpaid. He looks like he is over the hill and doesn't make much of an impact. Whatever Godchaux makes he's overpaid. Jonnu is looking more and more like a bust and Agholor was overpaid the minute the ink dried on that contract. That being said, for what they paid Judon, Bourne, and Karras those guys so far look like bargains.