Here it is everybody. The definitive officially official best edge prospect list compiled by yours truly.
Well, aside from the last bit, I did compile it, that's obviously guff. However I have tried to use PFF to come up with the best all-round edge prospects based upon stats rather than scouting. It is meant as a guide to scouting and nothing more.
What I have done is taken a prospects run defense grade and then added a simple pass rush formula (pressures +2 x sacks) to prioritise successful pass rushes. The two scores combined hopefully provides a list of edge prospects who are good against the run but are also successful pass rushers.
Here are the top 25
1. David Bailey
2. Rueben Bain
3. Keyshawn James-Newby (New Mexico)
4. Clev Lubin
5. Akheem Mesidor (all roads...)
6. Zion Young
7. Caden Curry
8. Melkart Abou-Jaoude (UNC)
9. Dani Dennis-Sutton
10. Isaiah Smith (SMU)
11. Derrick Moore
12. Cashius Howell
13. Will Heldt (Clemson)
14. TJ Parker
15. Romello Height
16. Damon Wilson II
17. Gabe Jacas
18. Mikail Kamara
19. Keyron Crawford
20. Teitum Tuioti (Oregon)
21. Stephen Daley (Indiana)
22. Kenyatta Jackson
23. Princewill Umanmielen
24. Malachi Lawrence
25. Matayo Uiagelelei
Interestingly, no Joshua Josephs, Keldric Faulk, R Mason Thomas or Anto Saka.
Take it FWIW.