Agreed but…I think we just did that with Milton Williams, Landry, and obviously already did with Dugger.
Kind of disagree. Dugger we did.
Williams we paid for a 1st tier player. Hopefully he will be.
Landry is being paid more like a 2.5 tier/3rd tier guy which is okay, and it is a short 2 year contract... technically 3... but really 2.
Dugger is the 2nd tier level contract. And it was a 4 year contract (so really 3) which makes it much much worse).
Typically here is what i mean by tiers of guys.
1st tier - Anyone who is likely to challenge for a pro bowl spot. This includes future HOFers... All pros, on and off pro bowlers... basically anyone who any year can have one of the best years in the NFL at their position. Typically guys in this tier can have issues or defects (age, maybe minor injury concerns, slight inconsistency) but if you are in this tier you are basically in it (unless you can't stay healthy or are constantly in trouble with suspensions looming over you..... even i that case the NFL might make an exception if you are a first tier player).
2nd tier - These are guys who typically don't challenge for pro bowls but are good players. But there is the HOPE they some day might turn into those guys. They are where you get in trouble. Particularly if they have no 'defect'. Guys like these who are young, no injury history and produce a fair amount demand high contracts with longer time periods. They can play well but rarely make the plays to turn games in your favor. These are guys you need to be careful when you sign. If you can't sign them to short term deals best not to sign them at all.. (short term meaning 1-2 year deals... but if a guy like this is young and has no issue that usually isn't possible).
2.5 Tier guys - These guys I am actually okay signing. 1 or 2 year contracts here are possible, which is what you want from these players.... Often coming off an injury... or older players who are trying to prove they still have it for 1 more contract or will rotate more now and their contract reflects that. Maybe they under performed in the previous year and now want to show they can be worth the next big contract. There can be real value here, and if you are wrong it hurts you a lot less.
3rd tier is basically guys you accept 100% won't be probowlers even in their best years.... You and they know they are not cornerstones of your team but a solid building block. These guys you get very good deals from typically. I like these contracts.
This is what i think Landry is... got paid his big contract and didn't live up.. now he is taking a 'discount' to play 2 years here to show he can be worth his final contract. Still 14.5M per year when all is said and done... but that right now puts him 23rd among edge players.. and because he just signed his contract this year... it isn't even as bad as that.
Milton is currently the 2nd highest paid DT in the NFL and signed long term. That is a 1st tier deal. They think he will be a guy who makes pro bowls while here. I hope he is.
Dugger is the issue though... even 1 year later he is the 11th highest paid safety. He was able to command a 4 (3) year contract which means they either need to pay him for 3 or eat a lot of cash after year 2.
I don't like to typically say a tier is the 11th highest paid or 20th highest paid or 8th... it varies by position. And it's relation to other positions. Like Safety and CB.... The first tier of CB's is deeper than Safeties... cause typically if you are a REALLY good DB you play CB. So that first tier is naturally deeper. Same for Guards and Offensive Tackles. QB is kind of its own thing and fluctuates.