Where I am now on such stuff.
It's Brady over Mahomes by a clear but not insurmountable margin, by which I mean I cannot exclude the possibility Mahomes could catch up. Tom has more SB wins, at two places, and a record of excellence over a remarkably long period. But still...
It's still Bill over Reid, but not by a hell of a lot, given Bill's pretty awful work, both as GM and as HC, over his last several years, and several real bonehead moves in regular season games and in at least one Superbowl. Then there are his near blindness to talent at certain positions, mostly but not entirely in his capacity as GM, his far-too-early write-off of Tom's abilities as Tom got older, his selfishly petulant and irresponsible mishandling of Mac Jones, and his unforgivably asinine decisions re more than a couple coaching hires,. I think it likely Andy will pass him by. I would not have expected that five or six years ago. The fact that no one in the NFL cares to hire Bill speaks not only to his age, but also to deficiencies which have been there if not all along, certainly for quite some time.
Bill vs. Tom.: Particularly given events subsequent to Tom's departure, you have to give the nod to Tom by - what? - 70% to 30%.
