NFL GAME DAY DISCUSSION Super Bowl Game Day Pregame/Game Thread (Eagles vs Chiefs)

[carmelo15]

Mahomes is gonna likely surpass Montana now though. Might take a long time though. Unless something crazy happens.

I try not to be a hypocrite. This was a HUGE pivot game I was saying it for weeks. 2-1 is so so much bigger legacy wise than 1-2. And so that’s where he’s at.

Brady’s legacy would have been irreparably damaged if Butler doesn’t make that INT and he falls to 3-3. But he did, he won and he was suddenly 4-2 and it only kept going. That’s how it goes.

He literally had no impact on the game the refs had more. Impact than he did

 

[carmelo15]

Mahomo looked to be in trouble only up 3 with 1:45 to play for an elite PHI offense. had to rig and end the game right there

only defensive holding call of the game btw

It PI even tho the call back in Browns catch was an easy pi

 

[StrawHatPatriot]

Aaron Rodgers and Peyton Manning are better QB's than Brady too.

Are they greater?

Talent means nothing.

Results are all that matter.

Objectively, that was a classic game with an awful ending.

They're even better than Brady. Brady still does certain thing Better than them

 

[Guts]

He literally had no impact on the game the refs had more. Impact than he did

Nah he played a clean game
Took what the defenses gave him
and scored on every 2nd half possession
He was great in the 2nd half
I don't like the ankle dramatics though

 

[carmelo15]

Nah he played a clean game
Took what the defenses gave him
and scored on every 2nd half possession
He was great in the 2nd half
I don't like the ankle dramatics though

Hurts had a better game despite that fumble and his ankle has been fine since the cincy game

 

[Patsfan1958]

Rhianna's hair made her look like a Dr. Seuss character

 

[Betterthanmost]

So Joe Thuney is quietly stacking up the Lombardis.

 

[Ollie]

In sports head to head is dumb. That might be the dumbest thing I’ve ever heard.

When talking about how one QB beat another QB it is dumb.

 

[SHOWTIME15]

He won't? He already did a very long time ago. Brady is better than the combination of the Mannings careers. So GTFOH.

He will always be owned by the Manning boys when it counts the most.

You mean all those Super Bowls with Brady game-winning drives? Brady's the indisputable GOAT. L

Hmm, kind of an interesting poll. Not everyone thinks Brady is the GOAT it would seem. And this was taken last week before Mahomes heroics yesterday. 64K people voted. Mahomes already has 40% on Brady and he’s just getting warmed up.

 

[NE_Zealot]

5-1 in the SB would do it. Mahomes so far has not lost in the playoffs to a bad QB. Brady has lost to Eli, Flacco, Plummer, Sanchez, Dak, and Tannehill.

Incorrect. My book says he needs 8 to outright pass, or win 7 and go to 11 Super Bowls. Your second point is ridiculous. You play in that many playoff games you’re going to lose some for a variety of reasons. The QBs play against each other’s defenses, not each other.

 

[SHOWTIME15]

Incorrect. My book says he needs 8 to outright pass, or win 7 and go to 11 Super Bowls.

Everyone has a different book. The most number of titles has never been the sole criteria for GOATNESS in other sports. Bill Russell is not the GOAT in basketball, despite having 11 titles (5 more than Jordan), Dimaggio is not the GOAT in baseball despite having 10 world series titles, and Messier is not the GOAT in hockey despite having 6 Cups (1 more than Gretzky). If Mahomes gets 5-6 chips but surpasses Brady in stats that would do it for me.

 

[SamusAranX]

Head to head is dumb, especially since Mahomes lost one of those playoff games to Brady on a pre snap penalty on Dee Ford.

“Head to head is dumb”….except when you downplay Brady for losing head to head to manning and foles.

 

[NE_Zealot]

Everyone has a different book. The most number of titles has never been the sole criteria for GOATNESS in other sports. Bill Russell is not the GOAT in basketball, despite having 11 titles (5 more than Jordan), Dimaggio is not the GOAT in baseball despite having 10 world series titles, and Messier is not the GOAT in hockey despite having 6 Cups (1 more than Gretzky). If Mahomes gets 5-6 chips but surpasses Brady in stats that would do it for me.

My book is the one that counts in this case. I can freely disregard other opinions

 

[SHOWTIME15]

I’m just hoping Mahomes takes it up the ass from the PHI D-line tonight

This aged well...LMAO

 

[Crazy World of Troy Brown]

Good thing for that Dee Ford penalty. He would have been in 4 SB's in 5 years, and a good chance they would have beaten the Rams, that year.

 

[The Brandon Five]

Everyone has a different book. The most number of titles has never been the sole criteria for GOATNESS in other sports. Bill Russell is not the GOAT in basketball, despite having 11 titles (5 more than Jordan), Dimaggio is not the GOAT in baseball despite having 10 world series titles, and Messier is not the GOAT in hockey despite having 6 Cups (1 more than Gretzky). If Mahomes gets 5-6 chips but surpasses Brady in stats that would do it for me.

You are full of it. Mahomes didn't even need to win this second one for you to pick him over Brady. Sell that b.s. someplace else, we're all stocked up here.

 

[PATSYLICIOUS]

Silver lining is max lane losing a game on a ticky tack hold. That will probably sting a long time for all eagles players /fans.

 

[sb1]

So easy to get that title now

Didn’t know Florio lets Nick Wright tweet for them.

 

[Pats2000]

Give Mahomes some respect, people. As fans of Brady and championship football for the better part of two decades we should respect greatness. Mahomes has two and was no small part in it.

I’d probably give the edge to Peyton Manning a little bit, still. But it’s nice to see another player other than Brady be great. It’s pure jealously and insecurity to feel otherwise.

188 yards passing is great? MVP worthy even? Maybe if this was the early 2000's, but now you apparently can't touch WR at all. So 188 yards passing is piss poor and Mahommes barely got it done. He did not play well.

 

[sb1]

Why is Brady being discussed right now?

We just witness a blatant bag job by the refs in the most obvious of circumstances in the biggest sporting event of the year.

Nothing to do with Brady.

Someone said Brady > Mahomes > Manning, @MAC10 saw that, got triggered and you can guess where it went from there.