Registered Members experience this forum ad and noise-free.
CLICK HERE to Register for a free account and login for a smoother ad-free experience. It's easy, and only takes a few moments.MassLive | Posted: 07/22 New! |
| How getting released by Patriots helped QB not be surprised after getting fired by ESPN |
MassLive | Posted: 07/22 👁: 30 |
| Patriots sign former track star to bolster tight end depth |
MassLive | Posted: 07/22 New! |
| Patriots sign young linebacker ahead of training camp |
Boston.com | Posted: 07/22 New! |
| 2026 Patriots training camp guide: What to know if you go, what to watch for, and key dates |
Boston.com | Posted: 07/22 New! |
| Cam Newton reacts to ESPN layoffs: ‘Nothing else could surprise me’ after being cut from Patriots |
| 2026 General NFL News/Discussion/Non-Patriots free agents 1 Reactions | 07/22 at 11:06 pm |
| Caution With Regard to Roster Additions -Check Out Last Year 1 Reactions | 07/09 at 3:38 pm |
Steve Balestrieri
| TODAY'S TOP POSTERS: | # | |
| captain stone | 1 posts | |
| Ring 6 | 1 posts | |
| raduray | 1 posts |
Top five in order (Presuming Rodgers wins SB):
1. Brady
2. Montana
3. Manning
4. Rodgers
5. Elway
I considered putting Marino at 5. But Elway did alot with lesser pieces throughout his career.
I just can't put Elway above Rodgers in this scenario where Rodgers wins #2.
The eye test. Stats. Accolades. Everything would be in AR's favor.
I guess he didn't make a "football move"...That was close
I guess I'll just ask a direct question:Roger Staubach and Steve Young both had higher passer ratings than Rodgers, adjusted for era, and both led league leading offenses year after year. Staubach was a member of the recent NFL100 team.
That's Super Bowl era, of course. We're cutting off guys like Unitas even though he accomplished a lot more than Rodgers while being the offensive focal point. Graham, Baugh, and Luckman would be above him as well. If I were a Packer fan and valued rings, I'd have more appreciate for Starr and Herber.
SF Steve Young...not even a question. How old are you anyway?I guess I'll just ask a direct question:
Better QB in your opinion:
Rodgers or Steve Young?
| 13 | 2K |
| 427 | 26K |
| 5 | 985 |
| 34 | 2K |
From our archive - this week all-time:
July 8 - July 23 (Through 26yrs)











