in a fuggles hop induced state last night, it came to me
we need a way to assess this draft
and here it is:
after the actual draft, we run the numbers of a drafted player's actual selection slot vs. where he was taken in our mock. the number of picks is irrelevant as an average will be taken.
example using the jets mock numbers and theoretical selection slots:
Bowe--25th
Wade--59th
McDonald--63rd
Satele--89th
assume:
Bowe--17th
Wade 57th
McDonald--68th
Satele--82nd
yields:
Bowe--(-8)
Wade--(-2)
McDonald--(+5)
Satele--(-7)
Totals--(-12)/#selections=(-3)
So the NYJ GM would get a (-3) value for this mock.
Any interest in this quantitative analysis of our mock? I suppose we can award a second category or ** for actually making an accurate selection.
under your scenario here is the results:
49ers- dryheat44 - ALLEN BARBRE OT MISSOURI SOUTHERN -9
49ers- dryheat44 - ANTHONY GONZALEZ WR OHIO STATE 10
49ers- dryheat44 - ANTONIO JOHNSON DE MISSISSIPPI ST -76
49ers- dryheat44 - BRANDON HARRISON S STANFORD -20
49ers- dryheat44 - DARIUS WALKER RB NOTRE DAME -100
49ers- dryheat44 - JOHN WENDLING S WYOMING -80
49ers- dryheat44 - PATRICK WILLIS LB MISSISSIPPI 0
49ers- dryheat44 - ZAK DEOSSIE LB BROWN -19
-36.75
Bears- chunkypony - ANTHONY WATERS LB CLEMSON -2
Bears- chunkypony - BEN GRUBBS OG AUBURN 8
Bears- chunkypony - BEN PATRICK TE DELAWARE -184
Bears- chunkypony - JORDAN PALMER QB UTEP -75
-63.25
Bengals- patsfan55 - ADAM CARRIKER DE NEBRASKA 5
Bengals- patsfan55 - LAMAR WOODLEY LB MICHIGAN 3
Bengals- patsfan55 - TRAVAROUS BAIN CB HAMPTON -100
-30.66
Bills- stinkypete - ANTONIO PITTMAN RB OHIO STATE -33
Bills- stinkypete - DAYMEION HUGHES CB CALIFORNIA -52
Bills- stinkypete - JACOBY JONES WR LANE 38
Bills- stinkypete - LAWRENCE TIMMONS LB FLORIDA STATE -3
Bills- stinkypete - TONY HUNT RB PENN ST 2
-9.6
Broncos- ayjackson - DAVID CLOWNEY WR VIRGINIA TECH -71
Broncos- ayjackson - JAMES MARTEN OT BOSTON COLLEGE 3
Broncos- ayjackson - JUSTIN HARRELL DT TENNESSEE 5
Broncos- ayjackson - VICTOR ABIAMIRI DE NOTRE DAME -1
-16
Browns- ironwasp - AARON ROSS CB TEXAS 16
Browns- ironwasp - BRADY QUINN QB NOTRE DAME -19
Browns- ironwasp - BRIAN LEONARD RB RUTGERS 15
Browns- ironwasp - MANNY RAMIREZ OG TEXAS TECH -14
-0.5
Buccaneers- bakes781 - AARON ROUSE S VIRGINIA TECH -25
Buccaneers- bakes781 - ERIC WRIGHT CB UNLV 49
Buccaneers- bakes781 - JOE THOMAS OT WISCONSIN 1
Buccaneers- bakes781 - RUFUS ALEXANDER LB OKLAHOMA -108
Buccaneers- bakes781 - TANK TYLER DT NC STATE -47
-26
Cardinals- primetime - GAINES ADAMS DE CLEMSON 1
Cardinals- primetime - H.B. BLADES LB PITTSBURGH -74
Cardinals- primetime - JUSTIN DURANT LB HAMPTON 21
Cardinals- primetime - TONY UGOH OT ARKANSAS -4
-14
Chargers- sebman2112 - AUNDRAE ALLISON WR EAST CAROLINA -84
Chargers- sebman2112 - BRANDON FRYE OT VIRGINIA TECH -67
Chargers- sebman2112 - BRIAN ROBISON LB TEXAS -9
Chargers- sebman2112 - KOLBY SMITH RB LOUISVILLE -19
Chargers- sebman2112 - MICHAEL GRIFFIN S TEXAS 11
-33.6
Chiefs- tampabaypats12 - DWAYNE JARRETT WR USC -22
Chiefs- tampabaypats12 - QUINN PIT**** DT OHIO ST -14
Chiefs- tampabaypats12 - RYAN HARRIS OT NOTRE DAME -16
-
17.33
Colts- gomezcat - CHANSI STUCKEY WR CLEMSON -95
Colts- gomezcat - COURTNEY BROWN CB CAL POLY -76
Colts- gomezcat - JON BEASON LB MIAMI 7
Colts- gomezcat - LORENZO BOOKER RB FLORIDA ST 24
Colts- gomezcat - XZAVIE JACKSON DE MISSOURI -150
-58
Cowboys- Seymour93 - JASON HILL WR WASHINGTON STATE -23
Cowboys- Seymour93 - JOE STALEY OT CENTRAL MICHIGAN -6
Cowboys- Seymour93 - MARCUS THOMAS DT FLORIDA 1
Cowboys- Seymour93 - USAMA YOUNG CB KENT ST -21
-12.25
Dolphins- VJCPatriot - DREW STANTON QB MICHIGAN STATE 17
Dolphins- VJCPatriot - LEVI BROWN OT PENN STATE 4
Dolphins- VJCPatriot - SIDNEY RICE WR SOUTH CAROLINA -4
Dolphins- VJCPatriot - TIM CROWDER DE TEXAS 15
Dolphins- VJCPatriot - YAMON FIGURS WR KANSAS ST 34
13.2
Eagles- Maroney39for6 - ROBERT MEACHEM WR TENNESSEE -1
Eagles- Maroney39for6 - TANARD JACKSON CB SYRACUSE -49
Eagles- Maroney39for6 - TIM SHAW OLB PENN ST -74
-41.33
Falcons- SamBamsFan - AMOBI OKOYE DT LOUISVILLE -2
Falcons- SamBamsFan - ANTHONY SPENCER DE PURDUE 13
Falcons- SamBamsFan - ARRON SEARS OT TENNESSEE 9
Falcons- SamBamsFan - DESHAWN WYNN RB FLORIDA -95
Falcons- SamBamsFan - JOSH GATTIS S WAKE FOREST -75
Falcons- SamBamsFan - KENNY SCOTT CB GEORGIA TECH -100
Falcons- SamBamsFan - MIKE WALKER WR CENTRAL FLORIDA 42
-29.71
Giants- Seneschal2 - CRAIG DAVIS WR LSU 21
Giants- Seneschal2 - MIKE OTTO OT PURDUE -107
Giants- Seneschal2 - PAUL POSLUSZNY LB PENN STATE -14
Giants- Seneschal2 - SABBY PISCITELLI S OREGON ST 17
-20.75
Jaguars- Irish Hooligan - ERIC WEDDLE S UTAH 11
Jaguars- Irish Hooligan - JAMAAL ANDERSON DE ARKANSAS 9
Jaguars- Irish Hooligan - JOHN BECK QB BYU 73
Jaguars- Irish Hooligan - QUINCY BLACK LB NEW MEXICO 11
26
Jets- Flying Fungi - DWAYNE BOWE WR LSU 2
Jets- Flying Fungi - JONATHAN WADE CB TENNESSEE -25
Jets- Flying Fungi - RAY MCDONALD DE FLORIDA -34
Jets- Flying Fungi - SAMSON SATELE OL HAWAII -29
-21.5
Lions- PushnPencils - CALVIN JOHNSON WR GEORGIA TECH 0
Lions- PushnPencils - JARVIS MOSS DE FLORIDA 17
Lions- PushnPencils - MARSHALL YANDA OT IOWA 15
Lions- PushnPencils - TRENT EDWARDS QB STANFORD -26
1.5
Packers- skaIownsIyou - A.J. DAVIS CB NC STATE 7
Packers- skaIownsIyou - COURTNEY TAYLOR WR AUBURN -119
Packers- skaIownsIyou - MICHAEL BUSH RB LOUISVILLE -53
Packers- skaIownsIyou - REGGIE NELSON S FLORIDA -5
-42.5
Panthers- ice - BRANDON MERIWEATHER S MIAMI 21
Panthers- ice - BUSTER DAVIS ILB FLORIDA ST 14
Panthers- ice - GREG OLSEN TE MIAMI -17
Panthers- ice - RHEMA MCKNIGHT WR NOTRE DAME -100
-20.5
Patriots- mavfan2390 - MARCUS MCCAULEY CB FRESNO STATE -44
Patriots- mavfan2390 - MARSHAWN LYNCH RB CALIFORNIA 12
Patriots- mavfan2390 - MARVIN WHITE S TCU 13
Patriots- mavfan2390 - STEWART BRADLEY OLB NEBRASKA 4
-3.75
Raiders- SeanBruschi54 - JAMARCUS RUSSELL QB LSU 0
Raiders- SeanBruschi54 - KENNY IRONS RB AUBURN 50
Raiders- SeanBruschi54 - QUENTIN MOSES DE GEORGIA 0
Raiders- SeanBruschi54 - RYAN KALIL C USC -26
Raiders- SeanBruschi54- DAVID IRONS CB AUBURN -94
-14
Rams- broadwayjoe - BRANDON MEBANE DT CALIFORNIA -3
Rams- broadwayjoe - DARRELLE REVIS CB PITTSBURGH -1
Rams- broadwayjoe - DAVID HARRIS LB MICHIGAN 5
Rams- broadwayjoe - JAY MOORE DE NEBRASKA 13
3.5
Ravens- Handel - CHARLES JOHNSON DE GEORGIA -22
Ravens- Handel - JUSTIN BLALOCK OG TEXAS -10
Ravens- Handel - PAUL WILLIAMS WR FRESNO ST 54
Ravens- Handel - TROY SMITH QB OHIO ST -37
-3.75
Redskins- Maroney TD - LARON LANDRY S LSU 0
0
Saints- zarakotas5 - ANDY ALLEMAN OG AKRON 0
Saints- zarakotas5 - ANTWAN BARNES LB FLORIDA INTERNATIONAL -11
Saints- zarakotas5 - CHRIS DAVIS WR FLORIDA ST -3
Saints- zarakotas5 - CHRIS HOUSTON CB ARKANSAS -14
Saints- zarakotas5 - ERIC FRAMPTON S WASHINGTON ST -39
Saints- zarakotas5 - IKAIKA ALAMA-FRANCIS DE HAWAII 0
-11.16
Seahawks- bakes781 - KEVIN KOLB QB HOUSTON 84
Seahawks- bakes781 - PAUL SOLIAI DT UTAH -23
Seahawks- bakes781 - ZACH MILLER TE ARIZONA STATE 17
26
Steelers- jct - ADAM KOETS OT OREGON ST -70
Steelers- jct - ALAN BRANCH DT MICHIGAN -18
Steelers- jct - BRANDON SILER LB FLORIDA -194
Steelers- jct - DALLAS BAKER WR FLORIDA -95
Steelers- jct - DAN BAZUIN DE CENTRAL MICHIGAN 15
-72.4
Texans- A.C. Vegas - DOUG FREE OT NORTHERN ILLINOIS -49
Texans- A.C. Vegas - J.L. HIGGINS WR UTEP 8
Texans- A.C. Vegas - LEON HALL CB MICHIGAN -8
-16.33
Titans- Patskers - BRANDON JACKSON RB NEBRASKA 17
Titans- Patskers - FRED BENNETT CB SOUTH CAROLINA -8
Titans- Patskers - JON ABBATE LB WAKE FOREST -100
Titans- Patskers - JOSH WILSON CB MARYLAND -5
Titans- Patskers - TED GINN JR WR OHIO STATE 10
-17.2
Vikings- broadwayjoe - ADRIAN PETERSON RB OKLAHOMA 0
Vikings- broadwayjoe - JOSH BEEKMAN OG BOSTON COLLEGE -58
Vikings- broadwayjoe - STEVE SMITH WR USC -10
Vikings- broadwayjoe - TARELL BROWN CB TEXAS -41
-27.25