TommyD4207
Experienced Starter w/First Big Contract
- Joined
- Jul 1, 2007
- Messages
- 7,099
- Reaction score
- 10,299
To be completely fair, Chase played the 2nd half of the season hurt every game, that didn't really help.Right, but if Chase was out instead of Burrow, I think Cincy makes the playoffs.
I'm back and forth, if we were at #2 or #1 it's easy to go QB.
It's only a question on MHJ vs Daniels because MHJ is such a generational prospect at Wide Receiver and Daniels is not at the level of Maye or Williams, based on the current consensus from scouts.
One other factor I don't think people consider (assuming these 3 players are great picks):
Maye is 21 years old, big and strong and his skill set as a passer that sets him up for a long career, so you could have a 15-year #1 QB.
MHJ is 21, receivers start to decline at 30+ but you still get 10 years as #1 receiver. Assuming he will resign with you.
Daniels is 24, his elite skill is his running ability, which means susceptible to injury and likely falls off at a younger age so might count on 8 years as a franchise QB.
Seems like a small, pretty meaningless point but I think it should factor in, which is why I would be willing to trade 3 #1's for Maye but would not for someone with Daniels skill set. What's losing the next 2 years of #1 picks when you have 15+ years of a #1 QB?
Your point about taking the 21 year old is spot on though. Penix is 24 with two bad knees, Daniels is 24 and hadn't done anything until this year (at least Penix has his history in Indiana behind him).
I certainly would never trade 3 number ones for Drake Maye, however.