I dont know about your system, I think it has alot of flaws. SOLID and AVERAGE should likely be combined simply because its subjective anyways. You over rate rookies, injured players and players who have never played in the system. How can you rate any of them above average before they play? If we have 23 players AVERAGE or better(thats ALL starters AND 2nd stringers)why did we have the 25th ranked Defense last year? The OP is so obviously a homer. And why is Meriweather AVERAGE yet you rate his backup as SOLID?? Brown is a bottom of the roster guy who will likely not make this team IMHO. We signed Barrett to an extension, I dont think he is given enough credit simply because he hasnt played for us being hurt. That said I wouldnt value him above bottom of the roster either. And the days of Koppen being above average are over, he was the weak link on the OL last year. Branch isnt far behind. Our TEs are all SOLID, but a higher distinction should be held for those who arent specialists...Gronk could be soon but Herny and Crump are specialists.You wouldnt know from looking at that spreadsheet that we had the 8th ranked offense and 25th defense. Lastly, you have a NOT NFL CALIBER catagory yet you never used it. Do you really think everyone on that chart will play in the NFL this year?? Our castoffs will surely be valued, but as we know what works for us doesnt work for everyone and I can guaranttee there are players that wont make a NFL team. Take off the rose colored glasses please and evaluate again. :bricks: