- Joined
- Jan 6, 2008
- Messages
- 6,085
- Reaction score
- 6,392
McGill really has brought a knife to a gun fight here. He's way over his head.
I really wish we had more smilies here: i want one of a little dude clapping.
Registered Members experience this forum ad and noise-free.
CLICK HERE to Register for a free account and login for a smoother ad-free experience. It's easy, and only takes a few moments.McGill really has brought a knife to a gun fight here. He's way over his head.
DiPiero is, by the way, not merely an agent. While he is a licensed sports agent, he also is a lawyer himself, with exceptional credentials and a listing in "Best Lawyers in America." (He also has as a peer review rating from Martindale Hubbel of BV. This is not their best rating -- AV is. But for more than 100 years, the Martindale Hubbel peer ratings are one of the hardest to get. The "B" in BV means his peers have rated him as "high to very high" for competence. The "V" means his "ethical standards" are "very high."
Joe Friedberg is one of the most preeminent criminal defense lawyers in the country. Not one of the guys you have heard about because they like to have their name on tv. He is an AV rated lawyer. Richard Sharpstein is also an AV rated lawyer with more than 30 years experience.
McGill is an unrated lawyer with 2 years experience who lists as his office address a DUI firm, which does not even have him listed as an associate on their web site.
DiPiero did everything right in this case. He contacted the FBI BEFORE the order of protection was sought. He had two lawyers independently contact Mr. McGill -- two lawyers of unquestioned ethics who can corroborate the story.
The problem with Mr. McGill's case is that you cannot offer to settle an order of protection case. His client must assert that she feels an immediate threat of imminent harm. Offering to settle that claim for money is virtually (if not absolutely) a per se ethical violation. Money cannot make a person stop feeling threatened. I suspect it is probably ethically improper for a lawyer in Florida ever to offer to settle a dating violence claim for money, under Fla's rules of professional conduct. Think about it -- how could you ever say "I think he's about to hurt me" but not still feel that way just because he gives you money?
McGill really has brought a knife to a gun fight here. He's way over his head.
Sounds like it might be a little more serious than that, since Dipiero was, apparently, willing to make a claim on Randy's homeowner's policy.
Sounds like it might be a little more serious than that, since Dipiero was, apparently, willing to make a claim on Randy's homeowner's policy.
Yes, for the medical bills. ER Visit. X-rays. Doctor. ETC. That visit probably ran in the 5K range.
Sounds like it might be a little more serious than that, since Dipiero was, apparently, willing to make a claim on Randy's homeowner's policy.
I just get the feeling that it's the events leading up to whatever "accident" occured that is really what's behind all this. If Randy was hanging out with her, having a few drinks, maybe smoking some weed....whatever, that's the part that her lawyers are trying to cash in on.
So, although the injury itself was not due to any kind of aggressive action by Randy, I'm sure they figured he'd pay up to prevent any discussion of him violating the NFL substance abuse policy, if he was in fact, doing so.
That may also explain why he didn't want her to go to the hospital, especially if he had to drive her there himself.
Bottom line though is that if her lawyer is found to have attempted extortion, that by far is the larger problem here.
I just get the feeling that it's the events leading up to whatever "accident" occured that is really what's behind all this. If Randy was hanging out with her, having a few drinks, maybe smoking some weed....whatever, that's the part that her lawyers are trying to cash in on.
So, although the injury itself was not due to any kind of aggressive action by Randy, I'm sure they figured he'd pay up to prevent any discussion of him violating the NFL substance abuse policy, if he was in fact, doing so.
Lets assume he was smoking weed.
The extortion is now well documented.
If she claims he violated the policy and he says he didn't we have "she says he says." With her credibility shot to hell. Godell can't punish him just because she says they smoked dope, if his blood was clean the next time he is tested.
What's ridiculous about trying that move is that there's no proof and no way to prove the allegations. The league isn't just going to take some ex-stripper's word for it, especially not one demanding $500k to keep Moss quiet.
And even if he was smoking pot, no drug test is going to pick that up two weeks after the fact. Athletes have such low body fat and high metabolisms that it would be out of his body at most a couple days later.
That may also explain why he didn't want her to go to the hospital, especially if he had to drive her there himself.
Or maybe he didn't want her to go to the hospital because she had no physical injuries. A bruised finger is not something you spend 3 hours in an ER to have looked at. Its something, that if it still hurts a few days later, or a week later, then maybe you go to your PCP to have checked out.