PatsFans.com Menu
PatsFans.com - The Hub For New England Patriots Fans

An Overlooked Detail of the Wells "Report": Wells unintentionally exonerates McNally


Status
Not open for further replies.

Ice_Ice_Brady

I heard 10,000 whispering and nobody listening
PatsFans.com Supporter
Joined
Apr 3, 2006
Messages
26,109
Reaction score
52,116
For about ten pages of the "report," the mustache takes the opportunity argue that McNally's restroom break was a major break from protocol. Despite that two Patriots employees swore that they had seen McNally walk the balls to the field unaccompanied by referees many times in the past, Wells, ever the pessimist (except when information comes out that hurts the Patriots) builds his case by interviewing a bunch of game officials. The absurdity is that he is asking a bunch of rotating NFL officials about Jim McNally, an employee who they probably don't even know, considering they may be on assignment at Gillette once a year at most. Their testimony that they also can't recall McNally walking the balls out by himself is yet another smoke and mirrors tactic in this dishonest report. Like most of the refs and NFL officials in this story, they sure seem to claim there are strict protocols when every piece of objective evidence suggests otherwise. It's almost like they were given the rulebook in advance and asked if they correctly do their jobs.

Regardless, Wells builds and builds the case to discredit McNally (yes, McNally presumably used the word "urinal" to describe a "toilet"- what an unreliable SOB.) The major focus though, is this: McNally violated protocol, which has never been done before, not in Walter Anderson's 20 years in the league. Anderson is conveniently praised for his honesty and integrity while McNally is portrayed as a liar.

Anderson tells Wells that McNally took the balls and that this was shocking to everyone since it has never done before. He emphasizes that he ALWAYS accompanies McNally to the field and supervises the balls and that McNally ALWAYS asks for permission to bring out the balls. McNally says the opposite, that it is kind of a loose understanding and not a big deal.

Except, after Wells sides with Anderson and concludes that McNally violated a sacred protocol - presumably to do something shady this one time - there is another reference to McNally when describing the events.

It happens when the weasel, Mike Kensil, has already concluded the Patriots have cheated, and just as halftime begins, he looks for the balls that he is now going to measure (and misrepresent to the media.)

It is odd, because at this point you certainly would assume he would find Walt Anderson, since the protocol is ALWAYS that the balls are supervised by Walt, the head ref. After all, Walt said so and the report proves it. So, just find Walt right, because he would be either carrying the balls himself or walking in lockstep with a Patriots equipment man, as the balls are brought to the locker room, thus sticking to this ironclad protocol.

Here is what happens, directly taken from steaming pile of crap that is generously called a "report":

Kensil lost sight of the Patriots game balls at the beginning of halftime, so he walked to the Patriots locker room to make sure they were not there. He asked Berj Najarian, a Patriots employee who functions as Coach Belichick's chief of staff, to check inside the Patriots locker room for the balls. After Najarian went inside the locker room to look for the balls, Kensil saw McNally carrying them from the field and told the Patriots security representative stationed at the door of the Patriots locker room to inform Najarian that he had found what he needed. This is consistent with security footage that shows Kensil near the door that leads to the Patriots locker room at 8:28:25 PM, and McNally turning the corner at the top of the tunnel and heading towards the Officials Locker Room with the ball bags approximately 15 seconds later.

I'm sorry, but weren't we just hammered in the head, for the previous ten pages, that McNally's "break from protocol" was absolutely unheard of and suspicious, and that Walt Anderson always accompanies McNally with the balls? Then why is McNally alone with the balls, while Anderson has already left the field and in the official's locker room, expecting that McNally will, unsupervised and without "express permission", dropping them off to the refs? I don't see anything in the story about Anderson running around screaming if anyone has seen the balls, frantically searching for them. Why? Because this is normal protocol, a loose understanding and minimum security of the footballs, which has always been the norm, consistent with McNally's testimony.

This brief description of events completely destroys the entire trumped up argument that Wells makes previously, which is that the only way McNally would be alone with the balls is by deception and breaking protocol, something that Anderson has "never" had happen prior to that game.

An investigator who isn't an evil assh0le working for Satan's redheaded stepbrother might have asked Anderson: "If you claim it is always ironclad protocol for McNally to wait for you and have you walk the balls with him, then why was he again alone with the balls at halftime, and why didn't you notice or care?"
 
Last edited:
Yet another point that proves what a sham the entire issue has been from day one.

If you really want to know how Brady preferred the balls, look no further than the text messages shared with the equipment guy's fiancée, which was obviously a message that was meant just for them, with zero thoughts or concerns about anyone else. There's your proof right there. Brady wanted the balls no higher than 13 psi. Done deal.
 
2 times at one game doesn't seem like an exception . Lucky the NFL had walt at this game :rolleyes: . So did the NFL pay off Walt? Or was it just the Pats who payed off Mac and JJ :p
 
Wasn't there a section of the Wells Report that he praised Walt Anderson and defended his integrity? Cannot find it in the Wells Idiocy, but it is referred to in PFT...

It is almost like an advertisement for Anderson.. it seems out of place in this "objective" report.. and almost as though everyone else is "unprofessional"...

“It is obvious that he approaches his responsibilities with a high level of professionalism and integrity,” the Wells Report investigators wrote.

Through its research, the investigators found that Anderson “is one of the few referees who personally tests the inflation levels of game balls prior to the game, rather than delegating that responsibility to another member of his officiating crew.”
 
If I recall correctly the context report cites video of him walking the balls to the field unaccompanied for the start of the second half.
 
It's also important to note that all of McNally's unaccompanied comings and goings took place after Anderson was specifically told to keep a close eye on the footballs.

On a tangent to this, I'd love to see Wells' notes from his interview with Anderson where Wells got him to admit he's not sure which gauge he used. Not just to see exactly how the conversation went, but also to see when it took place. I'm willing it bet it took place after Exponent ran their initial experiments with both gauges and realized they had to use the non-logo gauge to make their case work.
 
Now you know why Wells' notes suddenly became privileged and the investigation was no longer artificially deemed independent. Those notes would be a goldmine for Brady's lawyers.
 
Yet another point that proves what a sham the entire issue has been from day one.

If you really want to know how Brady preferred the balls, look no further than the text messages shared with the equipment guy's fiancée, which was obviously a message that was meant just for them, with zero thoughts or concerns about anyone else. There's your proof right there. Brady wanted the balls no higher than 13 psi. Done deal.

Another is that McNally specifically reiterates to Walt Anderson pre-game that Brady likes the balls at 12.5. Why is that even necessary to draw attention to himself if he is just going to deflate them anyway?

Wells can't even get out of his own way as hard as he tries. It's impossible to present even the most biased facts without them stuck to the truth.
 
Wasn't there a section of the Wells Report that he praised Walt Anderson and defended his integrity? Cannot find it in the Wells Idiocy, but it is referred to in PFT...

It is almost like an advertisement for Anderson.. it seems out of place in this "objective" report.. and almost as though everyone else is "unprofessional"...


All this glorifying hoopla about Walt Anderson's professionalism and his ability to recollect the pressure measurements of 24 or 48 footballs but when it counts most they say Walt forgot which gauge he used?
 
They could probably go thru all the old security footage and show McNally going unescorted for every game!
 
They could probably go thru all the old security footage and show McNally going unescorted for every game!

This issue may pop up again in other games with other teams. Someone is going to film a ball boy walk unattended onto the filed while Walt is being professional somewhere else.
 
Since Goodell now claims there was a "scheme" to deflate footballs, and neither the Wells report, the Vincent letter or the appeal decision make that claim, I wonder if the NFLPA can now ask for the Wells Report notes to be released as well.
 
This issue may pop up again in other games with other teams. Someone is going to film a ball boy walk unattended onto the filed while Walt is being professional somewhere else.


For his exemplary service , lying and covering up for Goodell he will no longer be on the field, he is now a Supervisor of Referees.. must be because the Wells Report gently massaged his testicles.
 
For his exemplary service , lying and covering up for Goodell he will no longer be on the field, he is now a Supervisor of Referees.. must be because the Wells Report gently massaged his testicles.

Wow, did not know that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.


TRANSCRIPT: Patriots QB Drake Maye Conference Call
Patriots Now Have to Get to Work After Taking Maye
TRANSCRIPT: Eliot Wolf and Jerod Mayo After Patriots Take Drake Maye
Thursday Patriots Notebook 4/25: News and Notes
Patriots Kraft ‘Involved’ In Decision Making?  Zolak Says That’s Not the Case
MORSE: Final First Round Patriots Mock Draft
Slow Starts: Stark Contrast as Patriots Ponder Which Top QB To Draft
Wednesday Patriots Notebook 4/24: News and Notes
Tuesday Patriots Notebook 4/23: News and Notes
MORSE: Final 7 Round Patriots Mock Draft, Matthew Slater News
Back
Top