- Joined
- Oct 10, 2006
- Messages
- 76,883
- Reaction score
- 66,866
So, again, it's not fair to compare Brady's stats to Manning's stats the past 6 years because Manning had better "weapons", but it's ok to compare Addai's stats to Maroney's even though Maroney plays on an offense(this year) that is healthy and that oppossing defenses are scared to death? Last time I checked, Marvin Harrison, Tony Ugoh, and Dallas Clark have all missed time on Indy's offense. Hence, the reason for their decline statistically this year. Also, it's funny how you are quick to compare the one stat you can hang your hat on(YPC) when comparing Maroney to Addai. However, you conveniently leave out the stats Addai is clearly puuting up better than Maroney(TD's, receptions, total yards). You Glass apologists never cease to amaze me. I remember the boneheads who used to say Drew Bozo was better than Troy Aikman because he had better stats.
And you continue to change your own argument. My response was to your nonsense comparing Maroney to Morris. You can't come back with a valid counterpoint, so you've now switched to blaming the players around Addai, and seem completely oblivious to the 2 points in that argument that pretty much destroy your response:
1.) Maroney's numbers were better than Addai's even before the Colts' injuries hit.
2.) If Maroney is a product of his offense, how is it unfair to hold Addai to that same standard? If you're going to claim that Maroney's YPC is merely a function of the Patriots offense, how is that same argument somehow avoiding your when you pimp Addai?
Honest and consistent evaluation continues to be something you prefer to avoid.