There are five, and only five, NFL teams that come into this week with 10 wins or more. The Giants are one of those five. And that 10 win Giants team is the only team in the NFL that's found a way to beat the Cowboys this year.
Fyi, this is a quote from my original posting: "If we are talking preferred matchups I don't understand why we would want Seattle, Dallas, Falcons over the Giants".
Using your own criteria (exclusive accomplishment, 10 wins, and beat the top team in the conference) we should want to face the Giants instead of Seattle. Seattle in one of only two NFC teams with the exclusive 4 losses or less, and Seattle has the far bigger feather in their cap of beating the AFC conference leader, the Patriots. As well Seattle has scored more points and allowed less points.
Doing a quick search here are some notable "fearful" Giants items:
-Except the Texans the Giants have the fewest points scored of
every single team in the payoff hunt.
-The Falcons have scored a massive 179 more points than the Giants.
-Seattle has allowed a tangible 39 points less
-*The Giants are 2-2 in December (albeit a 3 point win over Dallas is definitely a notable win, but they also have a notable and convincing loss to Pitt as well as a PO qualifying match loss to an also ran Philly team where they never held the lead once in the game).
- *The previous month, November, was clearly the Giants best month as they were 4-0. All 4 teams will finish as a losing season. They beat the no wins Browns by 13, the three win Bears by 6, the six win Eagles by 5, and five win Cincinnati by 1. ((take it a month further back to October, in 3 of their 4 games they got a wish washy close game win over the hapless Rams by 7, loss to Green bay by 7, loss to Minn by 13).
*It is quantifiable that "fearful" is much more likely than not doesn't describe the last two months, November and December, of Giant Football or justify fear of a Giants v Patriots SB rematch -- with the exception that a half decade ago and a full decade ago they were able to squeak by to gain superbowl wins against us.
Again, the Giants do not "suck" but they are not the team we should be noting as the one to fear. And I'm surprised that someone would even argue it based on the 2016 season.