We have a 5 game sample , how are we doing?
Let's start with the run D first and unlike the back end situation it has been fairly consistent with the core players. So the run D is the easiest thing to talk about with some certainty.
Pats in run D is 5th in YPG surrendered with 85.6 and 4th in YPA surrendered with 3.51. These numbers support the eye test. They've face dangerous running QBs like Allen and to a lesser degree Smith.. But also good RB play from Cook, Achane, Jeanty (who has been solid) and the pretty deep Carolina back field... no it isn't like they haven't played anyone good here. Considering that, we should be able to expect this front to hold up well as long as they are healthy no matter who they play more or less. And for what it is worth they have only surrendered 2 rushing TDs... so in those short redzone situations, they are hard to convert on on the ground.
Tonga has been fantastic in his role. Barmore and Williams certainly are not liabilities in run defense. Landry has been stout vs the run too. Spillane has had some hiccups but has been solid. And everyone else has pitched in well too. At this point is is hard to look at this run D and not be very happy.
As for the pass D, it is harder to really say. The 3 games without Gonzo were... less than impressive. Now 2 games with him and everyone is in their rightful slot. One against the hapless Panthers... once against the dangerous Bills offense.
I guess all you can do is look at both parts and see the difference... First 3 games they surrendered 333, 297 and 139 yards for 256 average (these numbers subtract sacks btw). They also gave up passer rating grades of 102.8, 115.5 and 96.1... all vs QBs who really aren't that good.
Next they surrender with Gonzo in there 197 and 245 with passer ratings of 84 vs Young (Dalton is garbage time as were those 58 yards he got... but whatever) and 103.3 to one of the best QBs in the NFL. So averages out to 221 yards and around a 93 or so QB rating...
So a nice step up... not a big enough sample to know anything... but clearly some big time improvement.
These are more broad strokes and we can talk about individual players more... but what do you think about this D right now? How good is it?