To nobody in particular…
Matt Stafford played 12 years in Detroit, he made the playoffs three times and went 0-3. One season with the Rams he went 4-0 in the playoffs and won a Super Bowl. It’s a team sport, QB is a part of team, not apart from team… they’re not magic unicorns. Seattle was the best team in football last season, Stafford played really well against them… the Rams lost because it’s a team sport.
NFL players need or really want guaranteed money… people here all the time say things like Boutte is under contract for this year, so he should shut his mouth and play. If he breaks his neck and never plays again, he has nothing to show for it. This is why contracts get negotiated a year in advance, these guys don’t want to do the high wire act without a safety net. Understand this when you’re wondering why Boutte is not at OTA’s.
Stafford should be a HOF QB but 12 years Detroit hurt his chances. People wrongly count Pro Bowls and ignore the fact that many other players are Pro Bowls worthy in years they didn’t make it. The dynasty Patriots suffered from this, many deserving players didn’t get voted in because fan voters hated the franchise… they were still elite.
It’s a team game, Stafford couldn’t win in Detroit… no QB in history could have. That’s how football works.
First off, Thomas Brady woulda won with Detroit
Secondly, okay, you could get hurt playing a violent game for a living, granted, and so long as it's not required in your contractual obligations, there's no law requiring you to do things like participate on OTAs. Okay, guys can choose to sit one out when it looks like they have to compete for their spots, and no harm no foul if the team isn't jumping out of their skin to sign you a year early. Other receivers (& your QB) aren't required to pretend you're awesome, and nobody's required to give you the exact job you want, when they perceive themselves as needing to do what it takes to get better (including doing better than they could if they tried to use
you as the no. 1).
Yeah it's a business, and part of this particular business has to do with chance of injury (your example of breaking your neck in practice). I don't believe OTAs are full-contact, are they? If not, its sort of a stretch to worry about the risk of injury. But okay, hell, if you (the receiver) so desire you could refuse to watch a clip on your surface because of the possible effect on your retinas.
All I'm saying in response is that yes, it
is a business. Yes, psychologically I empathize -- you want it to feel fun like throwing the ball around and running circles around kids from other colleges, but this isn't that, not anymore.
So, if you don't get the ball enough anymore, if it's less fun when another guy is brought in because he seems better than you, etc., then you absolutely
can go this way, and nobody's allowed to fire you for it. But it might not endear you to management and fans.
For every asshat who just loves to say FAFO, there's someone smarter not saying it and still keeping all options viable.
I guess in this mad collection of analogies, that other guy is somehow Matt Stafford. I've actually lost track, but that would bring us back around to the thread plot.