Not to take anything away from Manning, but...

[BradyManny]

I'm not trying to take anything away from Peyton just because I hate him, but his receivers are constantly wide friggin open and I just don't see him making the same kind of throws and decisions that TB has wowed us with over his career.

While this was not Tom Brady's best year by any stretch, I still believe Tom makes more impressive passes on a routine basis than Manning. Particularly in the 04 season, it felt like play after play, Tom was making passes that just made you think "damn, how'd he find him, how'd he get it in there" Wayne, Harrison, Addai, Clark, these guys are consistently WIIIIDE OPEN.

 

[Gene In Montana]

For as many yards as Manning throws for year after year, how many holding calls does his O-Line get??? Hmmm... Given enough time (for the receivers to get open) even Rex Grossman would look good. Well... Maybe not.