Actual Pats Fan
Pro Bowl Player
- Joined
- May 26, 2016
- Messages
- 11,428
- Reaction score
- 11,530
Manning belongs ahead of Elway, but neither belong in the top ten.The correct order for QBs... well, more correct lots of ties because comparing across eras is stupid. Seriously, the game is barely recognizable the further back we go
1.Sammy Baugh, because he turned the running back QB into the passer we know. Yes, he kind of invented it - he had three coaches. I admit this is kind of honorary and I'm screwing Sid Luckman .
2. Tom Brady
3a Otto Graham, 3b Bart Starr, 3c Joe Montana, 3d John Elway,
7a Peyton Manning, 7b Roger Staubach, 7c Kurt Warner, 7d Sid Luckman, 7e Bobby Layne, 7f Unitas
That is more than 10. I can see arguments for many being 7g. (Especially Moon who legitimately has a racism claim making him spend his prime in the CFL- despite the weird sex stuff later in life for him. )
They're babies given a ton of money and starting jobs with no competition, and must be judged that way.












