Kickers have ups and downs, and there's no doubt Ghost is down right now. But he's a good kicker, and he'll rebound.
I hate comparing him to Adam, but it amazes me how people are so critical of Ghost yet give a free pass to Adam. 3 Super Bowls will make us look back fondly, I get that. But let's not forget Adam's struggles. Even if we exclude the first few years of Adam's career and start from the Super Bowl season, here's what we find:
Overall FG
2001: 80%
2002: 90%
2003: 73.5%
2004: 93.9%
2005: 80%
2003 stands out as a significant down-year, especially sandwiched between 2 of his better seasons. 2001 and 2005 were not great years by any means. Meanwhile a lot of people have given up on Ghost after 4 kicks in 2 games.
You only had to look to the other sideline yesterday to see just how quickly fortunes change for kickers. Nick Folk was a Pro Bowl kicker for the Cowboys, got injured, recovered but struggled with his form and eventually got cut, and then wins the job in New York this season after being mocked by his head coach.
Meanwhile, the Cowboys replaced him with Shaun Suisham, a kicker cut by the team that was last in their division, who ended up missing some critical kicks. This season, the Cowboys are trying David Buehler, a kick-off specialist they're converting to kick field goals. He's 2 for 4 on the season, missing a kick each week. So far, Folk is 5/5 this season.
Which is a long way of saying kickers are a fickle bunch. All kickers will struggle, and it's easy to kick Ghost when he's down. But he's a solid kicker, and he'll rebound so long as we don't abandon him early.